MLPTP EVENT Who’s that Ghost Chatter WINNER ANNOUNCED

I had a fairly strong feeling it wasn't going to be Starlight Glimmer, both because the questions about the purple seemed to indicate it was only on the G3 by that point and because the aqua streak in her hair seemed blue enough for the "No Blue" to rule her out.

Meanwhile, Sunset Shimmer was also a contender under the "main character" clue, and nothing had ruled her out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I had a fairly strong feeling it wasn't going to be Starlight Glimmer, both because the questions about the purple seemed to indicate it was only on the G3 by that point and because the aqua streak in her hair seemed blue enough for the "No Blue" to rule her out.

Meanwhile, Sunset Shimmer was also a contender under the "main character" clue, and nothing had ruled her out.
Good point :) I didn’t think about the blue in her hair
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I had a fairly strong feeling it wasn't going to be Starlight Glimmer, both because the questions about the purple seemed to indicate it was only on the G3 by that point and because the aqua streak in her hair seemed blue enough for the "No Blue" to rule her out.

Meanwhile, Sunset Shimmer was also a contender under the "main character" clue, and nothing had ruled her out.
I had it narrowed down to either Lyra or Sunset Shimmer. I was just unsure if Sunset's eyes counted as "blue" or not (they're blueish), but in no universe is Lyra a main character so that's where the Sunset Shimmer guess came from.
 
I had it narrowed down to either Lyra or Sunset Shimmer. I was just unsure if Sunset's eyes counted as "blue" or not (they're blueish), but in no universe is Lyra a main character so that's where the Sunset Shimmer guess came from.
When some guesses “is the pony *insert colour here*?” We presume that refers to the pony’s pelt colour. ;)
 
Congratulations to the latest winner!
I hope your pony arrives soon :smile:
 
So... 4 ponies. One earth g1, g3 rainbow flash, one g4, one fourth pony possibly g1.

Yes, one blue, the is purple, the g4 has been in a reboot release, some multi colored hair.

No Pegasus, some multi colored hair, no purple g4, no orange, no extra symbols on any, no babies, no ss, no g2, no unicorns, no baby exists of the g1, no seapony, no unicorns.

Not g1 bowtie, lemon drop, powder, or posey.
Not g4 rarity, blossomforth, dj pon, or cupcake, birch mac, or rainbow dash.
 
Last edited:
This is a tough one @Skybreeze saved the best / hardest for last I see, I can't keep up so I wish you guys the best of luck on your quest.

*in the corner pouty faced eating the kid's Halloween candy
 
This is a tough one @Skybreeze saved the best / hardest for last I see, I can't keep up so I wish you guys the best of luck on your quest.

*in the corner pouty faced eating the kid's Halloween candy
It is certainly more difficult, but y'all are smarty pants and get them too quick. :p So, I decided to make the finial round extra - but the prize is also extra. ;)
 
So let's see... Two G1s, one G3 (already identified), one G4 with no horn. None are pegasi, none are foals.
One of the G1s is an Earth Pony, the other isn't. The other also is not a unicorn or a sea pony. So if it's not a pegasus, a unicorn, an earth pony, or a sea pony... that limits it considerably assuming it's a pony at all. Neither of them is a So Soft, and neither of them has a baby counterpart
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
So let's see... Two G1s, one G3 (already identified), one G4 with no horn. None are pegasi, none are foals.
One of the G1s is an Earth Pony, the other isn't. The other also is not a unicorn or a sea pony. So if it's not a pegasus, a unicorn, an earth pony, or a sea pony... that limits it considerably assuming it's a pony at all. Neither of them is a So Soft, and neither of them has a baby counterpart
I'm keeping my post above ^ updated. Here's so far.
So... 4 ponies. One earth g1, g3 rainbow flash, one g4, one fourth pony possibly g1.

Yes, one blue, the g4 has been in a reboot release, some multi colored hair.

No Pegasus, some multi colored hair, no purple g4, no orange, no extra symbols on any, no babies, no ss, no g2, no unicorns, no baby exists of the g1, no seapony, g4 doesn't have a horn.

Not g1 bowtie, lemon drop, powder, or posey.
Not g4 rarity, blossomforth, dj pon, or cupcake, birch mac, or rainbow dash.
 
So let's see... Two G1s, one G3 (already identified), one G4 with no horn. None are pegasi, none are foals.
One of the G1s is an Earth Pony, the other isn't. The other also is not a unicorn or a sea pony. So if it's not a pegasus, a unicorn, an earth pony, or a sea pony... that limits it considerably assuming it's a pony at all. Neither of them is a So Soft, and neither of them has a baby counterpart
How do you know if there’s two G1’s? ;)

There’s still some very critical questions that haven’t been asked. ;)
 
How do you know if there’s two G1’s? ;)

There’s still some very critical questions that haven’t been asked. ;)
Someone asked if the G1 was an Earth Pony. You said "Yes but also No". Sounds an awful lot like 2 to me. Unless... Hmm.

If there's not a second G1 after all, then...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
You forgot that there is some purple :)
Lol, I did! Thank you. That was even my question! I'm honestly not really trying much, just keeping my mind off life. :)
 
Back
Top