- Joined
- Jan 3, 2006
- Messages
- 7,328
The time has come ponies! Time to vote for your favorite pony Halloween costume! 
Your fellow MLPTPer's have been hard at work creating some spook-tacular costumes. Time to pick your favorite and yes, only one vote per person! Just to make sure our contest is totally fair, I'm withholding the names of the creators until after the voting closes (Sat evening EST). Then this thread will be edited to reveal our fabulous costume makers.
It will be a tough decision but there can only be one MLPTP Halloween Costume Champion!
1) Butterscotch as a Scarecrow by @DracoKat
2) Banana Surprise as a Banana... Surprise! by @MonsterIceCream
3) Minty and Sparkleworks as Trick or Treat, Friends are Sweet! by @stjarne
For reference:
4) Yum Yum as Medusa. Or maybe Yum Yum-edusa by @PonyMomma
5) Celestia as a Magician’s Rabbit by @ActionHank
6) Minty as My Little Cthulu (I can confirm there is a pony under there!) by @dragonlady
7) Wavedancer in Summer Wing cosplay by @dragonlady
8) German Sweet Clover as Sarah from Labyrinth (permission given for watermark) by @Jellybean
9) Summer Berry as Loot Llama by @maycrestmom
10) Tex as Post Malone by @Sassarazzmadazzles
11) Sky Skimmer and Flitter as Scooby Doo and Scrappy Doo by @strawberrypony32
12) Sherbert as the SMOOZE! by @MegaLeafeon
13) Baby Starbow for Baby's first Halloween by @vampyrefay
14) Steamer, Zipp and Princess Celestia as Jack Skellington, Zero and Oogie Boogie by @AzaleaArt
Your fellow MLPTPer's have been hard at work creating some spook-tacular costumes. Time to pick your favorite and yes, only one vote per person! Just to make sure our contest is totally fair, I'm withholding the names of the creators until after the voting closes (Sat evening EST). Then this thread will be edited to reveal our fabulous costume makers.
It will be a tough decision but there can only be one MLPTP Halloween Costume Champion!
1) Butterscotch as a Scarecrow by @DracoKat
2) Banana Surprise as a Banana... Surprise! by @MonsterIceCream
3) Minty and Sparkleworks as Trick or Treat, Friends are Sweet! by @stjarne
For reference:
4) Yum Yum as Medusa. Or maybe Yum Yum-edusa
by @PonyMomma5) Celestia as a Magician’s Rabbit by @ActionHank
6) Minty as My Little Cthulu (I can confirm there is a pony under there!) by @dragonlady
7) Wavedancer in Summer Wing cosplay by @dragonlady
8) German Sweet Clover as Sarah from Labyrinth (permission given for watermark) by @Jellybean
9) Summer Berry as Loot Llama by @maycrestmom
10) Tex as Post Malone by @Sassarazzmadazzles
11) Sky Skimmer and Flitter as Scooby Doo and Scrappy Doo by @strawberrypony32
12) Sherbert as the SMOOZE! by @MegaLeafeon
13) Baby Starbow for Baby's first Halloween by @vampyrefay
14) Steamer, Zipp and Princess Celestia as Jack Skellington, Zero and Oogie Boogie by @AzaleaArt
Last edited:
It’s so hard to choose just one, I wish we could choose at least two (although there’s way more than two favourites)