$ Price Check $ Trying to price ponies?

E

Ena

Teeny Tiny Baby Pony
Joined
Jul 17, 2020
Messages
4
Hello!
I've basically got a box full of old mlp toys I'm considering selling, but I'm not a collector, and I'm not sure I want to go through the effort of finding the price of the individual ponies. I have about 70 of the 'normal' ponies, and 7 of the vintage ones. I kind of just want to throw them all in one lot for ebay, and I was wondering what a good base price for that would be? I realize that since they're not individually listed, it's probably hard to tell, so I don't mind if it's a really low-ball price. I just want them off my hands (and to see if they're worth selling at all). Any guidance would be helpful! Thank you!
 
Thank you very much!

I think inserting the thumbnails is alright; if not, I'll post again with full images instead. If anyone would like a clearer picture of a specific pony, let me know!
mlp7.jpgmlp6.jpgmlp5.jpgmlp4.jpgmlp3.jpgmlp2.jpgmlp1.jpg
 
I'll see if I can do a quick appraisal for you ;)


1595083088253.png


These are not G1 or vintage ponies, they are retro releases from around 2007: http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Retro
You might be able to get $3-6 each for them.

If I were selling them, these are the prices I would aim for:

Red = $0.50 or less
Orange = $1-3
Yellow = $3-5
Green = $5-8
White = $10-15


1595083691505.png

^ Firefly (upper left) is the only true vintage G1 pony in your lot


1595083726603.png


1595083737723.png


1595083749799.png


1595083765185.png


1595083784229.png


Note: G3's aren't in high demand right now, so your results will likely vary, but that should give you a ballpark idea. If you try to sell as a lot at the higher end of all the price ranges, I doubt you will have any interest, so best to aim for the lower end of the estimate in order for a timely and successful sale. Good luck! ;)
 
MustBeJewel said:
I'll see if I can do a quick appraisal for you ;)


View attachment 31531

These are not G1 or vintage ponies, they are retro releases from around 2007: http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Retro
You might be able to get $3-6 each for them.

If I were selling them, these are the prices I would aim for:

Red = $0.50 or less
Orange = $1-3
Yellow = $3-5
Green = $5-8
White = $10-15


View attachment 31532
^ Firefly (upper left) is the only true vintage G1 pony in your lot


View attachment 31533

View attachment 31534

View attachment 31535

View attachment 31536

View attachment 31537

Note: G3's aren't in high demand right now, so your results will likely vary, but that should give you a ballpark idea. If you try to sell as a lot at the higher end of all the price ranges, I doubt you will have any interest, so best to aim for the lower end of the estimate in order for a timely and successful sale. Good luck! ;)
Click to expand...
Wow. That was an excellent assessment @MustBeJewel ! That's awesome.
 
*Drools in G3* You have some super nice ponies!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
On forums, or on eBay? I'm pretty sure they all tend to go for more than that on eBay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
ZeldaTheSwordsman said:
On forums, or on eBay? I'm pretty sure they all tend to go for more than that on eBay.
Click to expand...

This assessment is just based on my personal experience, and what I would sell them for whether I were on here, Ebay, or at a pony meet. ;) It all depends though, you never know when a bidding war or other unusual occurrence might happen. The market has been down for G3's in general, and they have been difficult to sell.
 
Oh my gosh, that's amazing, thank you so much! That helps a lot, since I really had no idea. I appreciate it you taking the time to do that, and I'll be sure to keep what you said in mind. And thank you to everyone else who commented as well!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top