$ Price Check $ Twice As Fancy First Tooth Ponies

L

LittleGiggles

Teeny Tiny Baby Pony
Joined
Mar 10, 2024
Messages
11
Hello! I have discovered my old G1 Ponies in storage. Just curious if anyone knows if the Twice As Fancy ponies are pretty common or more on the Rare side? Or typical price estimates for them? They have been played with and then sitting in storage so the manes and tails are not shining and curly still. Some have a few blemishes or spots. Thank you for any and all help!
I have:
Baby Sugarberry
Baby Melody
Baby Milky Way
Baby Dancing Butterflies
Baby Up Up and Away
Baby Sweet Tooth

plus Baby Fifi

DSC02275.JPG DSC02284.JPG DSC02296.JPG DSC02305.JPG DSC02312.JPG DSC02333.JPG 20240309_211946.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
the baby twice as fancy ponies (excluding baby fifi) are mail order only ponies and therefore sought after. they regularly fetch $80-$130 each, of course depending on condition. yours look pretty good from what i can see, hair is an easy fix.
 
Hair is good (pink hair is not faded much, no obvious cuts etc), good symbols (baby milky ways symbols often wear the most with the glitter but they all look ok), no obvious marks, chews or signs of rusting you could get even above 130 USD say 150USD on Ebay (ones selling below 125USD often have minor or obvious flaws, severe fading etc). incredible to find a set of 6 so they could be worth more but it would be easier to sell them internationally (larger market).

As previous seller mentioned Fifi is a first tooth pony and comes with accessories (peach toothpaste, blue toothbrush, star pants, sippy cup, toy xylophone and mallet, duck comb, ribbon); without them she is worth less (8-15 closer to 8 end), with accessories can go up to around 35.
 
Last edited:
I'm sooo intrested in baby sugarberry... sooo cute....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top