Unpopular Pony Opinions

Status
Not open for further replies.
I thought Lucky was their son?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
Well, I hate all the new pony lines, especially the G2 ones. I don't know why. some of the newer ones are sort of cute, but the first generation is the best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I honestly think the g1 cartoon is so terrible it’s good. I grew up in the 2000s, but I grew up watching the g1 DVDs. I recently tried to watch one and... yikes! The voices hurt my ears and the animation is painful to watch. But it’s so bad it’s entertaining. I only wish I could use subtitles.

I’m also totally obsessed with Gen 3 Rarity. As a child I made her be Lightly Lily and Star Catcher’s daughter. She’s probably my second favorite pony, next to Star Catcher.
 
I honestly think the g1 cartoon is so terrible it’s good. I grew up in the 2000s, but I grew up watching the g1 DVDs. I recently tried to watch one and... yikes! The voices hurt my ears and the animation is painful to watch. But it’s so bad it’s entertaining. I only wish I could use subtitles.

I’m also totally obsessed with Gen 3 Rarity. As a child I made her be Lightly Lily and Star Catcher’s daughter. She’s probably my second favorite pony, next to Star Catcher.
Disagree on the show (obviously) but hard agree on the subtitles! The fact that it's not illegal is no excuse for them never having subbed a 30-year-old show. -_- My poor sensory processing disorder had a real workout the first few rewatches, since it was so out of practice watching VHS-quality audio.

I'm also a big fan of G3 Rarity. She's my favourite of the "G4 ancestor" six, if not my favourite G3 overall!
 
I shouldn’t say this, especially since I have one for sale, but Starglow is one of the ugliest ponies ever created. Pink and dark green? She looks better in the dark.

same goes for MM Windy. Just ugly.
 
I shouldn’t say this, especially since I have one for sale, but Starglow is one of the ugliest ponies ever created. Pink and dark green? She looks better in the dark.

same goes for MM Windy. Just ugly.
Starglow is supposed to be dark blue, which does look pretty but she fades out to the weird green-ish Oscar the Grouch colour. (I’m happy I have her though. Otherwise I’d buy her from you again. Lol)
31A5B016-6019-4326-BE29-700BB947EC7D.jpegD89D1DA7-82BA-448A-ADF9-029915FDD809.jpeg
 
Well, here’s a new one: Super-Long-Haired ponies were a mistake. Sure, it looks amazing brand new, sadly it doesn’t hold up well! I have never seen a SLH in person that has perfect hair. It’s always awfully frizzy or “puffy”.
On the SLH topic, did we ever have longer-haired regular sized G4s, or was the hair quality that bad?
Also, factory curl? Not my thing. They look like a rat’s nest when it’s not “perfect”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I can't comment because I've never owned a SLH. G4s hair is too long as it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
.....still very much disliking the very minimal mlp section at my Walmart. It hasn't changed or improved all year long ;w;

They have the box with the various blind-bag-sized characters and only 2-4 of the mane 6 as the g4.5 3 inch brushables

.....their fakie selection is more exciting. ..
 
Starglow is supposed to be dark blue, which does look pretty but she fades out to the weird green-ish Oscar the Grouch colour. (I’m happy I have her though. Otherwise I’d buy her from you again. Lol)
View attachment 26588View attachment 26589

If Starglow looked like she does on the back of the package, I'd love her, but she doesn't look anything like that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
If I had PayPal, I'd so take Starglow the Grouch off your hands. I've been wanting one since I was a kid.


My unpopular pony opinion:
I don't like Ploomette.
 
If I had PayPal, I'd so take Starglow the Grouch off your hands. I've been wanting one since I was a kid.


My unpopular pony opinion:
I don't like Ploomette.
Message @Cactusflower im sure you guys can arrange something. ;)

I will always try to restore a pony before I use it as a custom. I don’t always see a pony as “bait” as some collectors do. 8(
 
Well, here’s a new one: Super-Long-Haired ponies were a mistake. Sure, it looks amazing brand new, sadly it doesn’t hold up well! I have never seen a SLH in person that has perfect hair. It’s always awfully frizzy or “puffy”.
On the SLH topic, did we ever have longer-haired regular sized G4s, or was the hair quality that bad?
Also, factory curl? Not my thing. They look like a rat’s nest when it’s not “perfect”.
Really? I got a Rainbow Flash from the thrift store and she had nasty hair. She cleaned up nicely though! I guess I don't see them with bad hair often, other than Rainbow Flash.
Ughhhhhhhh I can only imagine how bad Super Long Haired g4s would be. Thanks for the nightmares! :p
 
If I had PayPal, I'd so take Starglow the Grouch off your hands. I've been wanting one since I was a kid.


My unpopular pony opinion:
I don't like Ploomette.
How many people actually do like her though? It seems like a mixed feelings-type thing. I do to a point but I can understand the dislike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top