Does anyone else find this amusing?

Pinkie

Banned
Joined
Apr 1, 2012
Messages
433
thumbnail.aspx




In generation 3, Skywishes was an earthpony who envied her beautiful pegasus friend's flight abilities, and dreamed to fly like them. Starcatcher amazed her by commanding her butterfly friends to carry Skywishes as if she was flying.
thumbnail.aspx


In generation 4, they released her as a pegasus. The same pony, but with wings. Skywishes.

thumbnail.aspx



For those just joining us, we are also discussing:

How do ponies get their names?
What's behind Waterfire's name?
Why would hasbro change ponies so much?
Pinkie's Theory-Ponies in Evolution and Politics, Making sense of fiction.
 
Last edited:
You see, friendship IS magic. It gave her wings. Ta Daaaah!
 
i think they discovered red bull...hehe;)
 
It has always bothered me. Why couldn't they just come up with new ponies rather than mutating old ones? Total lack of imagination or something?

Because they already patented the names. They started patenting the names in G3, so we keep seeing G3 names being reused.
 
Because they already patented the names. They started patenting the names in G3, so we keep seeing G3 names being reused.

Also, for trademark purposes. If Hasbro doesn't reuse names every so often, they'll lose the right to use them at all.

It's the reason why Applejack and Spike are the only G1 characters to keep their names in FiM. They're the only G1 names Hasbro still had the trademarks to, if I'm remembering correctly.
 
Also, for trademark purposes. If Hasbro doesn't reuse names every so often, they'll lose the right to use them at all.

It's the reason why Applejack and Spike are the only G1 characters to keep their names in FiM. They're the only G1 names Hasbro still had the trademarks to, if I'm remembering correctly.
Naturally, as they were G1 names that also appeared in G3, when they were trademarked. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe they were the only G1 names directly "recycled" into G3 (as in, things like G3 Twilight Twinkle and G1 Twilight wouldn't count as they aren't exactly the same).
 
Naturally, as they were G1 names that also appeared in G3, when they were trademarked. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe they were the only G1 names directly "recycled" into G3 (as in, things like G3 Twilight Twinkle and G1 Twilight wouldn't count as they aren't exactly the same).

Yes, correct, which is exactly what I meant by G3 was the year that they trademarked or patented the names! I found an article a long time ago on MLP news about how ponies get their names, and the story behind Waterfire. Are we all familiar with this, or should I share the story? :)
 
Also, for trademark purposes. If Hasbro doesn't reuse names every so often, they'll lose the right to use them at all.

It's the reason why Applejack and Spike are the only G1 characters to keep their names in FiM. They're the only G1 names Hasbro still had the trademarks to, if I'm remembering correctly.


I didn't think of that. I suppose that makes sense. I'm still not fond of the Earth ponies sprouting wings but if they were going to have pegs, I guess someone had to!
 
I didn't think of that. I suppose that makes sense. I'm still not fond of the Earth ponies sprouting wings but if they were going to have pegs, I guess someone had to!

Ditto! At least Fluttershy looked like a completly different pony. Skywishes looks exactly the same! Cutiemark and all! She just has wings. It's so ironic, because she discovered pegasus ponies and when she told everyone in ponyville they didn't beleive her!

"Sky-are you sure this isn't another one of your.....Speical wishes?" -Pinkie Pie
 
Yes, correct, which is exactly what I meant by G3 was the year that they trademarked or patented the names! I found an article a long time ago on MLP news about how ponies get their names, and the story behind Waterfire. Are we all familiar with this, or should I share the story? :)
I would love to know, because that pony confuses the heck outta me!
 
I would love to know, because that pony confuses the heck outta me!

Well, this is what the article says:

"At the 2008 My Little Pony Fair, some of the MLP team were kind enough to talk to us about some of the details that go into making any MLP toy a reality. At the time, collectors were concerned why some G3 ponies had changed names between waves of the toys and the discussion of this lead to some interesting insights into how My Little Pony toys get their names. I’m going to try to recap this info as best as I can but someone may have a video of this discussion up on YouTube somewhere if you want the whole thing from the source.

The MLP team explained that naming ponies isn’t as simple as just making up a cute name. They actually have to go through a rigorous approval process for each and every name because My Little Ponies aren’t just cutie marked… they’re also trademarked. Before any pony name can be finalized, they have to make sure they aren’t running afoul of any other company’s trademark or copyright and many seemingly innocent names never made it past this stage.

They also mentioned that, for international markets, it’s easier when the pony has a nonsense name (say, Scootaloo) instead of a name made of real English works (such as Ivy or Firefly). If you notice, while many pony names in the earlier generations were common English words, the focus with the later generations has increasingly been on these “created†names that combine multiple words to make the name. The reason, according to Hasbro, was that they both ran into less issues with translations (imagine if a cute pony name in English meant something horrifying in another language) and, in many cases, didn’t need to translate the name at all. It must make it much easier on their marketing department if they can use the same name in both the English and international markets (not to mention how much less confusing this is for us collectors in the international world of the internet).

While all this was a fascinating look into the world of MLP to begin with, the woman we were speaking with shared fun little bit of trivia. Many times, the staff has tried to sort of sneak inside jokes or internal references past the censors and, though they rarely succeed, they succeeded at least once with Waterfire.

See, the Hasbro HQ is located in Pawtucket, Rhode Island. Nearby Providence, RI has an annual tradition called WaterFire which is a favorite of tourists and residents alike. "

On Waterfire's official webpage, it explains the event. Bonfires suspended in the river, Boats lit with fire, and sculptures installed to catch aflame in the water light up the night. Dancers are silhouetted by flickering flames, and visitors gather to see the marvel of Waterfire. It's all completely safe, and part of the draw is the seemingly impossible is achieved. It sounds really cool, actually. Pictures on Google show the rivers glowing with fire, and Birdseye views of the event show the whole city just glowing!
 
That's cool, Pinkie. Waterfire actually sorta confused me a little. She didn't have the playful/cutsey name that many ponies do.
 
Back
Top