Is this a good deal (Craigslist)?

[EmilyintheGlass]

This is listed for $40 on Craigslist. Is this a good deal?

 

[victorose]

Most of those ponies are from Year 2, and are pretty common. I probably wouldn't pay more than $25 for that lot, if that much.

 

[01mlplover]

i agree with the above comment. the most i would pay is $20.

 

[Beckie-Ann]

Yeah, that's over $3.00 a piece. *Sigh*

 

[Peppermint Truly]

I would have to say that if you don't have *any* of them and they're all for your collection it might not be such an awful deal ($3 a pony isn't bad), but if you only need a few, then I wouldn't pay that much.

 

[MLPWhitney]

I think that is overpriced, but if you dont have any then maybe you should go for it

 

[babyblueducky]

yeah, it does sound like a lot. people who post them on craigslist just know they go for a lot, but not what they are worth. $25 is more reasonable. i bought about 50 g3s with a few fakies for $25. it is up to you, if you have the money to buy them and you want them bad enough, go for it. from what i can tell in the picture, it makes them look like they are in pretty good condition. they look clean and hair cut free.

 

[Snork_Maiden]

I agree with Peppermint Truly. If you haven't got any of the ponies (or at least, let's say, 90%), it may be a good deal for you. Otherwise, it's simply too much money for fairly common ponies.