$ Price Check $ MIB G3.5 ponies - are they worth more?

[Dreamer]

I know that G3.5 is arguably the least favourite and/or sought after pony generation thus far and that the only ponies that are truly sought after (at least a little) are the two moms and maybe the mermaid Ponyville-style figures, but what about MIB G3.5 ponies?

I don't see them very often for sale in their original box, and often when I do see them they're normally for very high prices, so they don't sell. But I'm not sure if they don't sell because the price is too high, or because, even in the original boxes, they're simply bordering on being worthless to collectors.

 

[Sprout]

I would like MIB G3.5 ponies... but I'm pretty sure I'm one of the only G3.5 enthusiasts on the planet haha. I have a couple of MIB Newborn Cuties but I cannot remember how much I paid, probably not much though. And I'm STILL on the search for a Toola-Roola, she's the only Core Seven pony I don't have a G3.5 figure of.

I saw a Star Song in her original box (albeit with some box wear) on ebay Australia recently, apparently it sold for $6 plus $10 shipping (Australian dollars).
I'd say MIB G3.5 ponies are worth at least a few dollars more than out of box because they ensure new, clean condition and the artwork is cute. But still a tough sell it seems... Just need to wait for the right buyer to come along.

 

[Dreamer]

I was afraid that might be the case! I want to keep my deboxed G3.5s and sell the boxed ones for space reasons. I might just put them up for their original retail value, and maybe start lowering them if they don't sell I suppose, and hope for the best.

Now that you mention it, I think Toola-Roola was the hardest one for me to track down as well. I can't remember if I ever found her out of the box.

 

[Septima Windsong]

I was afraid that might be the case! I want to keep my deboxed G3.5s and sell the boxed ones for space reasons. I might just put them up for their original retail value, and maybe start lowering them if they don't sell I suppose, and hope for the best.

Now that you mention it, I think Toola-Roola was the hardest one for me to track down as well. I can't remember if I ever found her out of the box.

Toola-Roola was also the hardest one for me to find. Even though I found one (TAF variant), her hair is not perfect and she has some visible pen marks. I would buy another one in better condition, but unfortunately I can't find one in my country.