G3 (removed / edited)

[Sprout]

(I had to remove this because my brain gets fixated and panicked about small things and I was spending every waking moment fretting about the accuracy of the post haha)

(Original thread topic: Sought-after G3 ponies)

 

[StormMaeker]

Apparently Goodie Goodie and Darling Delilah were sought after I read once somewhere but I can’t say if that is still true

I am surprised about that version of Star Catcher. I do like her leg pattern but to me the fabric blue one has always been, to me, the ‘actual’ one

 

[Dreamer]

This is fantastic to see.

I'm curious if any of the other pegasi or unicorns have retained any sort of notable rarity. I know they used to be somewhat sought after, but maybe that's changed.

 

[Sprout]

Apparently Goodie Goodie and Darling Delilah were sought after I read once somewhere but I can’t say if that is still true

I am surprised about that version of Star Catcher. I do like her leg pattern but to me the fabric blue one has always been, to me, the ‘actual’ one

Goodie Goodie probaby, but I saw several affordable but unsold ebay listings of Daring Delilah, maybe it's just that Darling Delilah isn't as wanted... which is a shame because I have her and love her!
I think the fabric wing Star Catcher is still more popular but she seems surprisingly easy to find at least as far as I've seen hehe. Personally I like the plastic wing Star Catcher but still haven't been able to get her after a while :[

As for other unicorn and pegasus ponies, I haven't finished looking around at all of them online but most still had cheap unsold listings as far as I could tell!

 

[ninastoyshelf]

Wow this is very helpful and informative, thank you! I always wonder why certain items are more rare than others, especially if the toy line was very popular.

 

[Einhornbaby]

ah seeing these G3 makes my little heart happy, they are so pretty!!
Still missing Wind Wisher and WInter ice And I think Pepperberry, hmmmmm.

 

[Twinkle-eye]

Pepper Berry is cute :O

 

[Stellaluna]

This list is good to have for if I find any in the wild! I know I've come across Carribean Delight more than once in local Marketplace lots but I never acted on it because I didn't know she was rare.

 

[LNS]

Nice list!

I'm another surprised by that version of Star Catcher. Would not have guessed. Then again I wouldn't have guessed Pepperberry either.

 

[LadyMoondancer]

I would add all the G3 Birthflower ponies to the list. (Not the Birthstone ponies, which had better distribution. Both sets were Toys R Us exclusives.)

 

[Einhornbaby]

Oh yes, thats true, the birthflowers are really hard to get (still missing so many of them *sigh*)

 

[starbritesprinkles]

Here's my opinion.

Rare
2008 Toy Fair Press Kit
Breast Cancer Awareness Prototype - both versions
Aqua-Haired Graffiti SDCC Exclusive Prototype
18-inch Project Blank
Rosey Posey
Bay Breeze
Trolley
Frisco
Minty VI
Rose Garden
Lady Slipper
Snippity Snap
Licensing Show Pinkie Pie
Licensing Show Rarity
TAF Pony Project
Black Pony Project

Uncommon
First 50 Ponies
Dream Blue
Rainbowberry
Snowdrop Swirl
Petite Petunia
Rainbow Treat
Rainbow Bubbles
Beach Belle
Caribbean Delight
Port-o-bella
SLH Royal Beauty
Castle Bonus Royal Beauty
Crowning Glory
Pretty Palace
Birthflowers
White Pony Project
Winter Ice
Northern Lights
Winter Snow
Sunny Grace

Sought-After
Snow'el II
Minty VII
Aurora Mist
Jade Garden
Dream Drifter
Anchors Away
Minty II
Tink-a-tink-a-too II
Christmas Series
Darling Dahlia
Goodie Goodie
Silver Rain
Thistle Whistle

 

[maycrestmom]

^^^^ totally agree ^^^^ with that above rare list and then can we add this girl to the list? I got this MLP from hathorcat and I think she was supposed to be a project pony G3 as she's a styling size but they were never mass produced sadly (so wish these had been made)

also did you want to put all the SDCC/fair ponies in their own category? Otherwise I would maybe put them in the sought after as I don't think of them as rare