Unearthed my childhood collection of 88 G1 ponies

T

Tahtanista

Guest
Hi, I'm new here. :)

I just opened up the big box of G1 ponies I stashed away about fifteen years ago. I never thought they'd become rare or popular. I just couldn't bear to throw them away.

Most of them are in decent condition, but they were played with a lot, so some have damage, cut hair, dirt, rubbed off cutie marks, and stains... pen marks... other stuff. I was a stupid kid. Five are in quarantine just in case. I'm only starting to learn about pony cancer, mold, plasticizer break down and such.

None of them have original boxes or accessories or anything like that--only the pony. I've started researching a little bit which ones are valuable, and I haven't really decided if I want to sell any, but if anyone feels like giving me free advice about the value of my collection or individual ponies in it, I'd be happy to hear it. I can provide more details on condition of any particular pony, too.

Alphabetical by: unicorn, pegasus, earth pony, babies, sea ponies

UNICORNS
Fizzy: twinkle-eye
Galaxy: twinkle-eye
Glory
Gusty (2)
Majesty
Milky Way
Mimic: twinkle-eye
Moondancer
Pinwheel
Powder
Ribbon: so-soft
Tabby: twirly-tail
Twilight
Sparkler
Speedy: twinkle-eye
Streaky
Windy

PEGASI
Bouncy: so-soft
Dancing Butterflies
Flutterbye
Firefly
Masquerade: twinkle-eye
Medly
North Star: so-soft
Locket: twinkle-eye
Paradise: so-soft
Peppermint Crunch: scented pony
Skydancer
Twinkler: sparkle pony
Whizzer: twinkle-eyes

EARTH
Applejack
Bowtie
Bright Bouquet families: 2 fathers, 2 mothers, 1 baby
Caramel Crunch: scented pony
Cherries Jubilee
Confetti
Crumpet: so-soft
Cupcake: so-soft
Magic Hat: magic message pony
Magic Star: so-soft
Night Glider
Lemon Drop
Li’l Tot
Love Melody
Parasol
Princess Starburst
Quackers: twinkle-eyes
Quarterback: big brother pony
Ringlets: brush ‘n grow
Scoops
Scrumptious: so-soft
Shady: so-soft
Sky Rocket: sparkle pony
Sundance: so-soft
Surprise
Sweet Stuff: twinkle-eyes
Tex: big brother pony
Tootsie

EARTH – BIRTH FLOWER PONIES
Daffodil, March
Lily of the Valley, May
Cosmos, October
Holly, December

REISSUE COLLECTOR PONIES
Blossom
Blue Belle
Butterscotch
Cotton Candy
Minty
Snuzzle

BABIES
Baby Cuddles
Clipper
Baby Quackers: first-tooth pony
Baby North Star: baby sparkle pony
Lavender Ember
Lucky the Stallion
Baby Whirly Twirl: peek-a-boo baby pony
Baby Noddins: peek-a-boo baby pony
Speckles & Bunkie: newborn twins
Sniffle & Snookums: newborn twins
Baby Glory
Baby Moondancer
Baby Firefly: baby sparkle pony
Baby Surprise: pearlized
Baby Heart Throb: beddy-bye eye

SEAPONIES
Seawinkle
Wavedancer
Sunshower

Thank you!
 
You have a nice bunch of ponies there! From what I see, Mimic (in the Unicorn category) is your most valuable pony. By herself in pretty good condition, she goes anywhere from $60-$100. The rest of the vintage ponies you could probably get at least $5-$10 for each one.

Editing this:

Crumpet (so-soft), Lil Tot, Tex, Quarterback, Clipper (baby), Night Glider would also go for more than $10.
 
Last edited:
Hello! Nice collection from your childhood!!!!!! Congrats!
 
Wow what an amazing thing to find stashed away, it must have been real fun looking through it all! Congrats xxxx
 
Wow...bet that was exciting! I know my collection started after purchasing my home...I found boxes of old toys in the attic. I was so excited and they weren't even mine as a child!
 
Also the pearlized baby--probaly worth more than $10 as well, depending on condition. I see those go for $20 ish most of the time (again, depending on condition).

Are memories flooding back? :)
 
Wow so exciting. Wish I could find a box like that around here. You can fix them up, clean them, maybe get some of the stains off with magic eraser and maybe even have someone fix the ones with haircuts...I know if they were my childhood ponies I would totally do this. I agree with the others...Mimic is your prize!
 
Rock-on! That's lots of gems! Woo! Cool!
 
congrats on finding them once more that is cool. I had the same feeling when we cleaned the attic and found ours some of them went with two of my sisters and i got the rest of them. Slowly i have been adding more gen one members to the herd.
 
Nice list of ponies to stumble on after all those years! The final price of a pony can vary depending on many things, the condition, how many people want it (I just saw a mimic in mint condition sell for around $55 on EBay but have also seen them sold for $150) if you choose to auction it, etc etc. So Soft Crumpet I would start at $30 -depending on condition. Pearlized ponies, probably $10-$15 to start.
 
wow that is so fun!!! how exciting! how fun it must be to go through all those memories!!! :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top