Who was your first baby pony?

[Miss Lilac]

Baby Yoyo? It was either a burnt baby pineapple I found at school in the out of bounds area, or Baby Yoyo.

 

[babyblueducky]

Here is a picture of me with my Baby Surprise on my 4th birthday.

 

[bluerose9978]

I believe mine was Baby Glory.

 

[RedTabbyKitty]

My first baby was Cotton Candy, She is still top of my cutest baby pony list

Side tracking a little I never knew teeny tiny babies, BBE's or rainbow babies even existed till I started collecting (hoarding) ponies as a grown up..... but then I never knew about SS's or TE's either........ such a sheltered life

 

[RedTabbyKitty]

Oo and the teeny tiny twins never knew about them either

TWICE AS GOOD!!!!!!!

 

[PrincessLyra]

My first baby was Baby Cotton Candy, for no other reason than @fantasticfirefly had one for sale and since I wanted to buy a Sherbet from her, I figured I'd get a bonus to make the shipping quote less heavy. She and Baby Glory sold me on the idea of Baby Ponies in general. The best part about her, though? Still has G1 smell!

 

[piinkypiie]

Baby starbow, big top and toppy (they came at the same time)

 

[Cerulean]

Baby Cuddles.

 

[mexicanmlp]

The only one I remember getting (opening) is Baby Drummer. I still have him =3

 

[Stellaluna]

I can't remember the first baby from my childhood collection. Might've been Baby Whiskers from the teeny tiny's? I know when I returned to MLP later to revive my collection hobby the first baby I got was Lucky, if he counts?

 

[Elfpony]

In order of generation:
Baby Cotton Candy
Baby Jewel and Sparkle
Pink Sunsparkle
Sweetie Belle

Elf

 

[Fluttershy]

I think mine was a plain white one sent off for by mail order. I can't remember her name if she even had one, might have just been "Baby Pony" or something like that.