MLPTP EVENT 2016 MLPTP Halloween Swap Wishlist Thread

Peppermint Truly

Rockabilly husky tamer
Jun 10, 2005
YAY! It's time for my favorite swap of the year! Please post your wishlists here.


Little Pretty Kitty
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 5, 2011
My Wishlist (G1):
  • Baby Moondancer
  • Birthflower January Carnation
  • Little Whiskers
  • Any Nurse Pony
  • Catnip the Cat
  • UK Baby Cuddles
  • Heart Throb (ss or nss)
  • Little Tabby
  • Mommy Pony
  • Cheif
  • Wigwam
My Wishlist (G3):
  • Port-o-Bella (I can dream, can't I?!)
  • January Carnation
  • January Joy

My Wishlist (G4):
  • New Big Mac with picture on side (all about series)
  • Derpy Hooves Equestria Girls Mini
Side note: Halloween themed ponies of any generation are totally awesome and I would love them. I am also cool with re-hairs and customs.

Flaws that are Acceptable:
  • slight smoke smell
  • minor haircuts
  • small scuffs on body and/or face as long as they still display okay
  • small amounts or regrind or discoloration
  • marks on bottoms of hooves
  • fading
  • missing accessories/no accessories
  • dry hair
  • Really, if you're a not too picky collector and you'd be okay with it, so will I!
Flaws that are not Acceptable:
  • cancer/big old moldy patches
  • major haircuts (really applies to manes more than tails, I can deal with a cropped tail, but not a full buzz cut)
  • big bite marks or missing limbs
  • huge, glaring marks on eyes or symbols
  • I am diabetic, so if you can find sugar free candy, that would be awesome. If you can't find sugar free candy, that's okay too, I can survive without sweets.
  • I am allergic to dogs, but as long as no one was intent on mailing ponies wearing dog hair sweaters, it should be fine.
What I like about Halloween and other Fun Tips:
  • I love cats a lot, so anything with black cats or witches on it is super cool.
  • I also love possums, raccoons, mice, sloths and pterodactyls.
  • Rarity and Derpy are my current favorite ponies, so I love anything with them on it.
  • I also like costumes, fall scents, spiderwebs, skeletons, monsters, and owls.
  • I am okay with scary stuff and cute stuff in equal measure.
  • I don't like grape or coffee flavored stuff. I like chocolate and pretty much any other flavor.
  • I like new and weird stuff, don't be afraid to surprise me!
  • I really like Halloween/fall in general since my wedding anniversary is in October, so have fun with this!
Last edited:


Festive FelizNavidad Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 3, 2006

I'm not too picky, no major hair cuts, or really bad marks, no chewed on or missing limbs LOL! But little flaws or marks and such don't bother me.

I like cooking/baking and decorating for the holidays. I love Snoopy/Peanuts, Eeyore, Garfield and I also collect Charming Tails. I have a dachshund that is my fur-baby :) so I tend to collect dachshund stuff too. I also collect gnomes and I like mice but not Mickey, nothing against good 'ol Mickey but I just like cute mice stuff. I like fun socks and jewelry, particularly earrings.
As far as Halloween stuff goes I like cute Halloween themed stuff, I'm not really into the gross/gory stuff. I like it all, bats, pumpkins, witches, ghosts...I get into all the holidays and love this time of year!

None! I am trying to diet though, so little or no treats is ok with me. If you find you can't resist, I like chocolate, peanut butter and toffee and since it's that time of year, of course pumpkin too! If you're international, I do love trying new things from different countries.



Flat Foot Peachy
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 16, 2014
~ Wish List for Halloween Swap ~

Pony Condition Preferences: I prefer ponies without cancer, major pen marks and major hair cuts. I'm not keen on regrind but a couple of small spots are acceptable. I don't mind some imperfections as long as the symbol and eyes are good, small rubs are ok. Small hair trims and marks to bottom of feet are ok too.

Twilight (unicorn)
TAF Love Melody
TAF Sugarberry
Minty CF or FF
Snuzzle CF or FF
Daisy Sweet
Dainty Dahlia
Cranberry Muffins
Pillow Talk
So soft FiFi
So soft Ribbon
Any of the Birthflower ponies except June/ December
Baby Blossom


Halloween: I prefer the cutsie side of halloween - black cats, cute ghosts, pumpkins etc. I don't like gore and blood or zombies. I am a fan of Nightmare before Christmas especially Jack Skelletington

My likes:
I am a big fan of Peanuts ~ Snoopy in particular. I also love disney stuff, especially tsums tsums (the small ones). Disney Characters I particularly like are Winnie the Pooh and friends, Aristocats, Minnie and Mickey.
I love Moonmins.

I like stickers, stationary items such as pens, pencils, erasers, notepads, post its or fridge magnets, reusable shopping bags (especially if of any of the characters mentioned above!) I love lip balms and I like homemade items and art. Socks are good also - I have medium sized feet!
I would be happy with some halloween decorations as we don't have many, something to put on or in the window would be cool. Halloween themed kitchen items would be welcome, such as cookie cutters, tea towel, mug.

Favourite animals: cats, owls and rabbits. We have just got 2 kitties ~ Sunny and Marshmallow

My favourite scents are autumn and winter scents such as cinnamon, spice, cranberry. I also like fruity smells. I like liquid soaps, shower gels, body lotion

Chocolate - I like milk and white chocolate. Chocolate with caramel, marshmallow, nuts all good! I don't like coconut, marzipan, Turkish delight, peanut butter
Sweets - I like gummy sweets. I love laffy taffy. I don't like black liquorice
Chips - I love Cheetos, cheese and the jalepeno and cheese flavour.
Drinks - I like drinking coffee and hot cocoa especially topped with marshmallows! I don't drink tea!
I don't have any allergies


Turn Your Color Up!
Oct 6, 2013
Ology's Hauntedly ghoulish list of Ponies!


Not picky on flaws just nothing with marker or words on it. No super bad hair cites.

I Collect G4 I DO NOT LIKE PINKY PIE sorry just putting this out there!
Ponies to Unearth
Twist and twirl Applejack
Rarity in the travel purse she is plastic no plush
TRU Princess Luna Plush Funrise large.
Friendship express train set with princess twilight

Land To Sea Rainbow Dash

FS Seapony Fluttershy
FS seapony Twilight Sparkle

Princess Skystar
Tempest Storm in hover car Guardian of harmony
Pirate Applejack Guardian of Harmony

SongBird that sings.

Pearlized pony
Sappier Joy -most wanted
Sea Swirl
Meadow Flower

Fake G4 Princess AppleJack, Rainbow Dash, and Rarity, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie

Older G4
Magic and Motion

Rarity carousal Bouquet
Rarity with breezie

New light up
Rainbow Dash hoof lifes up and you brohoof it to light up there is a pinkie pie one too.

My little pony nightmare Night set
I need Spike with his bed costume and scroll to complete my set.

Build a bear
sea pony capes
Song bird
Tempest storm

What I love about Halloween. Everything. I love pumpkins. Ghost hunting. Ghost stories. Scary movies, Ouji. Dressing up MUMMIES I LOVE MUMMIES AND HAUNTED DOLLS>
Trick and treats
I love old school movies black and white: mummy, creature from the black lagoon, Dracula, wolfman.
I love gore and haunted house stuff.
I live purple lights
Black and purple colors
Black cats
Pumpink candles
I Really really love mummies and ghost
Freddy and Jason movie.
Paranormal books
Autum things
Any thing with fall leaves yes even a little yellow.
Candles with fall smells except pumpkin spice.
Those fall jelly clings of leaves and pumpkin you put on Windows.
Favorite candy:
Cherry suckers
Cherry twizzler
Candy corn
Milky Way

Paranormal stuff
Old creepy dolls- I REALLY LIKE DOLLS LOL
Ghost storybooks
mummy/Egyptian things
Fun Halloween socks
Stickers creepy ones
Ouji Boards
Voodoo string dolls kits
Dowsing crystal
scary movies

Allergies: banana, latex, lotion, certain scented thing. ( I not allergic to everything lol. Not so much allergic but super sticky candy I cant really eat.

Don't like sounds strange but there just a few small thing I don't like at all.
Color yellow (gold in small bits ok small small bits of yellow I can handle)

Nuts in candy I just can't eat this

No clown stuff. I love horror gore all that stuff paranormal to the max but hands down please for the love of the gods no clowns. Thank you.

Spiders no thank you.

Yes I have a horrible horrible fear of clowns and spiders. Please no IT joke I hate that movie.
Last edited:


Princess Rinse 'N Spit
Dec 24, 2010
Halloween Swap Wishlist


Raspberry Jam
Cherry Sweet
Princess Skylark
Baby Pockets
Baby Hoppy
Tiny Bubbles
Baby Rainribbon

Rhythm and Rhyme
Fair Weather
Finger Paint
Flitter Flutter
Silver Rain

Pursey Pink
FIM Collection Luna
FIM Collection Derpy
FIM Collection Moonlight Chariot w/ bat pony
Funko mini Derpy Pony- glow in the dark
Guardians of Harmony Queen Chrysalis set
FS Photo Finish
Funrise Luna plush

Condition Preferences:
Acceptable: Minor haircuts and friz, marks on bottoms of hooves, small or removable marks and minor eye/symbol rub. I'm not very picky.
Unacceptable : Major haircuts and friz, permanent marks all over body, cancer, mold and large amount of eye/symbol rub.

Allergies: No food allergies. But heavily scented things can bother my allergies.

Candy likes and dislikes:
Likes: Milk and dark chocolate, chocolate covered pretzels, chocolate and peanut butter, gummy candy, anything blackberry, raspberry or strawberry flavored. This time of year my favorite candy is Reeses peanut butter pumpkins.

Dislikes: Coconut and licorice

Halloween is my favorite holiday. I love everything about it. My favorite things are decorating and dressing up. I usually make my own costume every year. And I love seeing new Halloween decorations come into stores. Some of my favorite decorations/Halloween things are bats, black cats, all kinds of monsters skulls and skeletons. I like scary and cute Halloween things. My favorites are when they both combine into creepy cute.

I also love horror movies. My favorite is Trick R Treat. I just adore Sam, one of my favorite movie monsters!

The only Halloween related item I don't like is spiders. Spiders terrify me. Please don't send any spiders in my box!


Princess Rinse 'N Spit
Mar 21, 2014
~Spooky MLP Wishlist~

Note: I love KAWAII spooky.
Halloween Aesthetic: Cute ghosts and bats are my absolute favorite!
Fall Aesthetic: Pumpkins and Leaf Items
Purple & Black are my fav colors.
Dove Dark Chocolate, Sour Patches, and Take 5 are my candies of choice.
I like stationary items: stickers, pens, sticky notes, etc.
Socks: Love fun socks, just not toe socks.
Non-MLP Obsession: Pokemon! (Raichu & Sylveon are my favs)

Equestria Girl Minis:
  • Sunset Shimmer Pep Rally (Single)
  • DJ Pon-3 Fall Formal (Single)
  • Flash Sentry Fall Formal (Single)
  • Fluttershy Fall Formal (Single)
  • Rarity Fall Formal (Single)
  • Rainbow Dash Fall Formal (Single)
  • Rarity Pep Rally (Single)
  • Twilight Pep Rally (Single)
  • Pinkie Pie Pep Rally (Single)
  • ANY of the MLP Mymoji Funko Figures (they come in mystery (2 count) packs)
  • Pop: Fluttershy Glow-in-the-Dark (Walmart Exclusive) (2016)
  • Pop: Twilight Sparkle GLITTER Version (2016)
  • Pop: Twilight Sparkle Glow-in-the-Dark (Walmart Exclusive) (2016)
  • Pop: Rainbow Dash GLITTER Version (2016)
  • Pop: Rainbow Dash Glow-in-the-Dark (Walmart Exclusive) (2016)
  • Pop: Pinkie Pie GLITTER Version (2016)
Guardians of Harmony:
  • Princess Celestia
  • Princess Luna
  • Shadow Bolt
  • Rainbow Dash
  • Pinkie Pie
  • Shining Armor