$ Price Check $ Help!

[MegansPlace]

Hi again! I'm wondering if anyone can tell me if any of the below are valued at more than the standard $4/$5 range (or maybe worth less)? Thanks in advance!

Star Dasher
Rainbowberry
Flower Garland
DaisyJo
Petal Blossom
Snow 'El
Round 'n Round
Bumbleberry
Twilight Twinkle
Sunshower
Star Flower
Tropical Surprise
Dream Blue
Strawberry Swirl
Breezie
Denim Blue
Lovey Dovey
Sweet Sparkle
Royal Twist
Lulabelle
Jade Garden
Fun Fairy
Fluttershy
Amberlocks
Cotton Candy
Serendipity
Cherry Blossom
Scooter Sprite
Savannah Sage
Twinkle Twirl
Comet Tail
Cherrilee
Toola Roola
Sunset Sweety
Seascape
Tangerine Twinkle
Butterscotch
Merriweather
Star Catcher
Hidden Treasure
Silver Glow
Sunrise Song
Garden Wishes
Rarity (regular symbol, not pop-out symbol)
Pinkie Pie
Sparkleworks
Star Swirl
Strawberry Surprise (w/ice cream)
Lily Lightly (still works w/cape)
Baby Honolu-Loo (Played w/cond, possibly bait) - Price suggestion???

Also, wondering what baity boys run? I've seen around $8, didn't know if this is common?

 

[eatontabby]

those are all about $3-4 baby honalu-loo you said possibly bait, if you have an image its easier to say her value..otherwise between 1-3

 

[obsessedfae]

I would say between 2 and 4. I would buy the Tropical Suprise and Strawberry Swirl if they are MIB.

 

[StrawberryReef]

If they are in great NM condition, I would price them all about $3, except for the following

Snow'el - $5-8
Fun Fairy - $5-8
Star Catcher - $5-8 (if it is the original one with fabric wings)

I know the unicorns sometimes go for more, so possibly $5 for those and $4-5 for the pegasus. Baby Honolu-loo usually goes for more too, but I don't know with her being in bait condition... maybe $3.

The only other one that stands out is Lily Lightly, but I don't personally know how much attention she draws.

If they aren't in great condition, I would reduce by $1 from the estimate above for good condition, and reduce by $2 for fair condition.

Hope this helps.

 

[BabyStarbowMLP]

I've sold my boy baits for $5 before. I feel bad asking for much more.

 

[bestinthewest]

"Baity Boys" as in Big Brother Ponies? I'm a little confused! lol

 

[MegansPlace]

Yep! I have Barnacle & Slugger who I think are Played with/Baity condition (I need to check them over again though). Thanks!

 

[eatontabby]

you have to keep in mind though with the market and everything if you price things at their highest they are not very likely to sell.

 

[MegansPlace]

Thanks so much for everyone's opinions! Eatontabby, I totally understand. I've been selling/trading ponies online for over 12 years and have seen the pony world thru lots of changes!

 

[MonsterIceCream]

Hey Megan, With the Baity boys, Ive sold them in the past for between $3- $5..... the white boys usually sell quickest....

I agree with SS, I've seen boys who are in 'okay' condition usually go for about $8-10, more so if they only have tiny flaws. So bait ones shouldn't be more than $5, unless their flaws are minor/easily fixable. But a lot of my price-predictions are from before the big economic issues, so I might be wrong.

 

[Mimic]

hmmmm......I don't know what these go for,luckily SS does