MLPTP EVENT MLPTP 2016 Secret Santa Wishlist Thread

Peppermint Truly

Rockabilly husky tamer
Jun 10, 2005
Please post your wishlists here once you have been accepted into the swap. If participating on multiple categories, please specify that here as well.


So Soft Pony, So hard to clean
Sep 7, 2008
My wishlist
I would love any G1 pony but I have another wantlist
I tried to check the prices forgive me if I went over one of the ponies that it wasn't on there or something. I use bluerose’s price guide.



sea star
sea shimmer
surf rider
sea breeze

Plush Ponies:
Cotton Candy

4-Speed -
O hard hat
O bandana, purple

Barnacle -
O pirate hat
O bandana, golden yellow

Chief -
O bandana, yellow

Quarterback -
O football helmet
O bandana, pink

Salty -
O sailor hat
O bandana, green

Slugger -
O baseball cap
O bandana, light greenish blue

Steamer -
O conductor's hat
O bandana, light yellow

Tex -
O bandana, blue

Wigwam -
O headdress
O bandana, greenish blue

Wigwam -
O headdress
O bandana, greenish blue

Princess Royal Blue
O wand, purple-pink

Princess Serena
O wand, purple-pink

Princess Sparkle
O wand, aqua

Princess Starburst
O wand, bubblegum pink

Princess Tiffany
O wand, blue

Princess Dawn
O wand, green

Princess Misty
O wand, light aqua

Princess Moondust
O wand, pink

Princess Pristina
O wand, raspberry pink

Princess Sunbeam
O wand, darker blue

Princess Taffeta
O wand, yellow

UK ponies


Good Weather

Baby Pony (all white)
Baby Fun 'n Games

Baby Explorer
Baby Nightsong

Baby Katie
Baby Billie

Baby Moondream

Love Token

Cherry Sweet

Music Time

Posey with dark tulips

Candy Kisses
Kiss & Make Up

Mail Orders:

Birthflower Ponies (white/pink):
Daffodil (March)
Rose (June)
Holly (December)

Mail order Spike

(Individual Ponies)

Stockings, the Holiday Pony


Other countries: I dont have many from any other countries. I like Italian ponies or any other country. I prefer pegasus ponies or unicorns.

For extras, I would like to have the cute animals, cute things ect. If sending candy make sure it is sugar free. Sugar free herseys, reeses, jolly ranchers are awesome. :) I have two cats and a almost 7 year old daughter. My favorite holiday colors are blue and sliver. I love herbal teas. non caffeinated. My other obsessions are Hello Kitty, horses, rainbows and shiny crystal jewelry. I like flower scented things like lavender, jasmine, gardenia, lily or roses. My favorite body washes in the world are Nivea just not classic Nivea.
Last edited:


Little Pretty Kitty
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 5, 2011
My Wishlist (all G1):
  • Baby Moondancer
  • Birthflower January Carnation
  • Any Big Brother besides Salty, Barnacle, or Steamer
  • Little Whiskers
  • Any Nurse Pony
  • Catnip the Cat
  • Snuzzle (cc or ff)
  • UK Baby Cuddles
  • TE Galaxy
  • Heart Throb (ss or nss)
  • Little Tabby
  • Mommy Pony
  • Buttons (ss or nss)
I am okay with a small amount of hair cutting, age spots, color fade, markings of bottoms of hooves, re-hairs, and anything that isn't super noticeable on display. Pink hair fade and very light smoke or perfume smell are okay too. I am NOT okay with cancer, animal smells, extreme haircuts, missing tails, or mold.
In addition to ponies, I like Monster High and Ever After High (dolls in general). I love cats and possums. I like Sanrio Characters, Moomins, Glitter Force, Pokemon (especially Espurr), Disney tsum tsums, and anime (current favorites are Attack on Titan and Black Butler). I have Diabetes, so it's okay if you don't want to include sweets. If you do, I like everything except grape and coffee flavors.


Flat Foot Peachy
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 16, 2014
Secret Santa Swap Wishlist

Pony Condition Preferences: I prefer ponies without cancer, major pen marks and major hair cuts. I'm not keen on regrind but a couple of small spots are acceptable. I don't mind some imperfections as long as the symbol and eyes are good, small rubs are ok. Small hair trims and marks to bottom of feet are ok too.

G1 Ponies
CF Minty
FF Minty
CF Snuzzle
FF Snuzzle
Twilight (Unicorn)
Cranberry Muffins
Daisy Sweet
Dainty Dahlia
Pillow talk
Sand digger
Sea Flower
So soft Cherries Jubilee
So soft Fifi
So soft Ribbon
TAF Sugarberry
Any of the Birthflower ponies except June and December

G1 Accessories
Barrettes for sundae best ponies ~ need Swirly Whirly, Crunch Berry
Candy cane ponies ~ any
Lollipop brushes pink

G3 Ponies
December Poinsettia
January Joy
November Chrysanthemum

Extra info:
My favourite colours are pink and blue. For christmas I like the classic christmas colours such as red, gold, green. I also like the blue/ silver combo!

My favourite scents are fall and winter scents such as cinnamon, spice, cranberry. I like liquid soaps, shower gels, body lotion

I like any MLP G1 Merchandise and
I also have a Lickety Split army
I am also a big fan of Peanuts ~ Snoopy in particular. I also love disney stuff, especially tsums tsums (the small ones). Favourite characters are Winnie the Pooh, Mickey and Minnie, Aristocats. I like stickers, stationary items such as pens, pencils, notepads, post its or fridge magnets, tote bags (especially if of any of the characters mentioned above!) I love lip balms and I like homemade items and art. Socks would be good also

Favourite animals: cats, owls and rabbits.

I love Autumn and Winter, my favourite holidays are Christmas and Halloween
I like cutie christmas things like snowmen, snowflakes, penguins, reindeer and santa! I also like the grinch.

I have a 4 year old son called Henry who is crazy about Thomas the Tank Engine and Curious George!

I like milk chocolate and gummy sweets and laffy taffy. I don't like coconut, marzipan, Turkish delight or liquorice. I also like savoury snacks especially cheese crunchy Cheetos

I like drinking coffee and hot cocoa especially topped with marshmallows! I don't drink tea!

I don't have any allergies
Last edited:


Turn Your Color Up!
Oct 6, 2013
My Wish List
Thing that turn me off on ponies are highlighter marks on the bodies. Really Really bad hair and tail cuts. The smell of smoke on ponies.
I am ok with light play marks.

G4 is what I collect mostly

Funrise Princess Luna plush major want you can get her at toy r us only
Toy R US friendship is magic Rarity with purple cape she a special edition and is about 7.00

Friendship Express train with twilight

Guardian of harmony
Twilight vs Changling-most wanted
Shining armor- most wanted
Spike vs Chrissy- most wanted
Rainbow dash low on list
Large Spike he is the most expensive

Pearl/shiny version of the Mane 6 and Starlight Glimmer, Pretzel Twist, Cherry berry
the 3 inch rarity with the bow head band.

Nightmare night mini figure set I still need these are at TOYS R US and are about 2.99 or so each.
Rainbow dash as shadow bolt
CMC sweetie bell and apple bloom dressed up
Spike with costum and bed

Midnight in canterlot this is the most expensive on my list.

Baby Skyla

Everfree EQG

Bright Glow

Silver Glow

Other thing I like. Peppermint, Chocolate, Cherry suckers, Divinity . Fuzzy socks with no rubber grips on them I also like sock with funny saying or pictures on them. I love Frozen the movie stuff but not Olaf. I love Labyrinth or David Bowie. I love chocolate. I love pins I put them on everything. I like paranormal stuff. Creepy dolls. The color purple, black, silver, and blue.
I like books on Lizzie Borden, Haunted objects Dowsing. I love monster high Cleo or Clawdeen, Ever after high ( I do not like apple or kitty) I like Raven or Cerise hood, I love Five night at Freddy's spring trap and mangle are my favorites

I hate the color yellow, grape flavor, Olaf the snow man, anything with big eyes. And the elf on the shelf scares me beyond words.

I can't have anything with latex in it and nothing with nuts. I am also allergic to mohair and most lotions.
Last edited:


Sep 15, 2015
My Wishlist
G 1

Twilight Glory Majesty Powder Gusty
Lickety-Split Shadey
Fizzy Gingerbread Masquerade SweetStuff Whizzer SweetPop Speedy Skyrocket
TicTacToe BrightEyes
Parasol Sunlight Windy Starshine
BabySurprise BabyBlossom BabyCottonCandy BabyTiddlywinks
SeaStar SeaShimmer Backstroke TinyBubbles Splasher SurfRider
SweetTooth Up, Up, and Away Merriweather Buttons Munchy YumYum BonnieBonnets
SunnyBunch BrilliantBlossoms FlowerBouquet Tassels DiamondDreams
Raincurl Ringlet Stripes
Napper SkyRocket Stardancer Sunspot Twinkler
SSPosey SSLofty SSNorthStar SSParidise SSFifi SSTwilight SS

Simi Grails
MilkyWay StarHopper


G3 Wishlist
Pariwinkle SapphireShores AugustsShores
MLPFair2009 SilverRain Wysteria2 ArtPonyUnderwater
StarBeam AnchorsAway IslandDelight ShellBelle DreamBlue TwinkleHope MistyBlue Moondancer CometTail SilverGlow VelvetBow MINTY

Aurora Mist
No pony cancer & highlighter marks
Hair cuts,pindot and ingrained dirt are ok I love cleaning ponies!
I also would love to have g1 baits

Extra info
Favorite animal:hORSES!
Favorite color:I love all shades of blue/teal
Extra favorite stuff:I love soda smelling stuff and I love tropical stuff like stuff with seashells and tropical flowers
Food:Note that I am allergic to peanuts and wheat(gluten) but I LOVE chocolate and caramel stuff
This Christmas I ask my family for blind bags such as MonsterHigh minis,Fnaf,NumNoms,Breyer miniwhinies

(sorry I know I put all my favorite ponies even though they don't fit into the price range,but I also LOVE hand made stuff of said ponies!)​
Last edited:


Fraser, your wolf just ate my jelly doughnut!
MLPTP Supporter
Feb 5, 2012
I was a late addition, so here goes (I'm participating in the low swap, so please ignore the high-cost ponies at the link):

Candy likes: Chocolate covered cherries (especially dark chocolate ones!), anything peppermint, hot chocolate.... and anything chocolate in general!
Favorite candy: Reeses cups and pieces. I also like dark chocolate.
Candy dislikes: Really sticky stuff (taffy, caramel, etc.)... I love it, but my dental work doesn't! Also, no coconut or any nuts other than peanuts and almonds (both I love in chocolate), nothing sugar-free, please. The substitutes make me sick. :p

I have three cats and a chihuahua if that helps.
Holiday Likes: Reindeer, snow (I'm from the north, i miss my snow), angels, red and green, blue, anything cutesy. Anything with the word "HOPE" on it... it is my very favorite word. Not big on religious stuff (except aforementioned angels). If ornaments are purchased, please no glass/easily breakable... I have cats, and they love my tree lol...
Favorite scents/tastes: peppermint, cherry, strawberry, apple
I do like spicy smells (pumpkin especially). Also love cherry, orange, chocolate and trees for smells.
Pumpkin pie!!! I could live off of that!!!!

ONE HUGE THING I'M LOOKING FOR: It's an odd request, and I doubt I'll ever find it again.... Glade's scent called "country garden" .... it would have to be THAT one. It came in air freshener and carpet powder. Knowing glade, possibly a candle as well. I lost my best friend of 21 years last year, and this scent smells EXACTLY like her house. I have a can that my grandmother still had, but barely any is left. I have searched high and low for anyone who might still have this discontinued scent in stock and am coming up empty. It could be anything in the line, as the freshener would probably not be able to be sent through the mail. But if you find it somehow, some way, (just by chance, don't stress yourself out over it) I'd be FOREVER in your debt. I just figured I'd include it on my wishlist, because I know different places have different things.

Anyway.... pony info:

My favorite gen is G1, I have no REAL allergies, and I love to draw and write.

Flaws that are okay: light hair trims, light marks / marks that can be sunfaded, hair that can be redone.
Flaws that are NOT okay: Pony cancer, smooze, missing body parts / chew marks, highlighter or dark marks.

I'm very easy to please.... not picky at all. :)

I think that's it! :)

(Same as last I'm off to do a little wishlist updating)