MLPTP EVENT Who’s that Ghost Chatter WINNER ANNOUNCED

Wait, so there isn’t another G4.5?
So let me get this straight.
There’s 5 ponies.
There are no G2s, and no G3.5s.
There is confirmed one G3, confirmed one G4.5, not two G1s, and not two G4s.
Then what the heck could the fifth pony be? And they’re all ponies so it wouldn’t be, like, an Equestria Girls doll.

Am I missing something?
 
I wonder if there's a fakie? Or g4 reboot, not g4.5? What do you think?
 
yourpinkoverlord said:
Wait, so there isn’t another G4.5?
So let me get this straight.
There’s 5 ponies.
There are no G2s, and no G3.5s.
There is confirmed one G3, confirmed one G4.5, not two G1s, and not two G4s.
Then what the heck could the fifth pony be? And they’re all ponies so it wouldn’t be, like, an Equestria Girls doll.

Am I missing something?
Click to expand...
She said they all have hooves.
 
Well... we're down to two choices on the g1. Just need more info on the fifth pony.
 
AzaleaArt said:
That’s what I was thinking too
Click to expand...
yourpinkoverlord said:
That’s a good idea, but wait, wouldn’t you still consider that to be in a Gen tho? Like it’s not like a plushie of Minty from 2007 wouldn’t be G3...
Click to expand...
Maybe retro? I’m just stewing here, trying to come up with what is possible... maybe a breezie, maybe a new retro release g1 or g3, but it’s retro, so doesn’t count, maybe bab, maybe plushie, we asked seapony but not merpony, would she count a funko ? I’m so lost.
 
This round is having me like
65A32830-2FBA-48E1-8084-B8A6B1887C42.jpeg
 
Tak said:
Maybe retro? I’m just stewing here, trying to come up with what is possible... maybe a breezie, maybe a new retro release g1 or g3, but it’s retro, so doesn’t count, maybe bab, maybe plushie, we asked seapony but not merpony, would she count a funko ? I’m so lost.
Click to expand...
It occurs to me - maybe the fifth pony isn't a plush, but the G1 is? Is that a possibility, or have all the G1 plushes been ruled out by other answers?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
What do we think about there maybe being a Dream Beauty under there? I’m not sure if they even actually count as mlp but would they fit with the answers we’ve gotten so far? :smile:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I bet everyone would have been really thrown off if there was a custom under there
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I'm still confused, haha, so one is a G1 released in year 8 or is the 2nd pony also a G1, and this one was released in year 8? But in that case, we would have 2 G1s (as opposed to the statement that there aren't two G2s). :unsure:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
IceCrystal said:
I'm still confused, haha, so one is a G1 released in year 8 or is the 2nd pony also a G1, and this one was released in year 8? But in that case, we would have 2 G1s (as opposed to the statement that there aren't two G2s). :unsure:
Click to expand...
I think you guys are confusing yourselves. ;)

We've already established that there's only 1xG1(still unknown who), 1xG3 (Rainbow Flash), 1xG4 (Pinkie Pie), 1xG4.5 (Potion Nova) and the last is still a mystery. ;)

Think about the things you guys know about the G1, then focus on the 5th pony. That's my suggestion.
 
Ha yes, I'm sure it's me, sometimes I think too much. :lolpony:

Exactly, so I'm unsure what the 5th one could be, as we've already ruled out all generations, including G3.5. I can't imagine it's a Takara as they cost half a fortune. :lolpony:

Now it probably depends if the already mentioned Dream Beauties are considered G1 or not....:blink:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top