In your opinion which one of these is more rare?

M

mlpsayuri

Banned
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
1,287
I know everyone has their own opinion on which ponies are htf based on their own collecting experiences. And I've come up with a list of ponies, and wanted to know in your own experiences which ponies have you found are more htfer to find?

My pretty pony brown or pink?
seashell or bubbles?
trickles or flutterbye?
sanddollar or wave jumper?
ss angel or ss crumpet?
taf munchy or nightglider?
cool breeze or starry wings?
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set?
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes?
baby leaper or baby racer?
baby gametime or baby sugarcake?
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony?
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal?
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn?
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies?

And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory?
 
My Pretty pony Pink
Seashell
Flutterbye
Sand Dollar
SS Crumpet
TAF Munchy
Cool Breeze
princess pony crown clip
princess brush n grow barrettes
baby racer
baby sugarcake
mommy and baby pony
uk baby sapphire
surprise newborn
sleeping pj plush ponies

The most HTF G1 accessory is a princess clip in my opinion...! :D
**hugs**

Mario~
 
re

My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? Seashell is harder to find in minty condition.
trickles or flutterbye? Again, Old purple ponies IMO are harder to find in minty condition... they always look grey... But at the same time... I see Tickle for sale 10 times more than Flutterbye.
sanddollar or wave jumper? Dont know.
ss angel or ss crumpet? I actually see Crumpet for sale more than Angel...
taf munchy or nightglider? Nightglider is harter to find.
cool breeze or starry wings? Both.
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? Crown clips dont really exist do they???
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? BNG
baby leaper or baby racer? Racer.
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? Both
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? Mommy and Baby
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal?
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? Surprise NB
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? PJs
 
Pink (not sure)
Bubbles
Trickles
Sand Dollar
tough, I think Crumpet
Nightglider
Cool Breeze
Crown Clip
Sundae pony barrettes
Leaper
another tough one, game time maybe?
Mommy and baby (not sure)
UK Baby Sapphire
UK Surprise Newborn
UK Sleeping PJ's
My guesses on American ponies are combined of what I find in thrift stores and what I see available as trades and on eBay and such, UK stuff is my best guess from seeing trades and whatnot.
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? SEASHELL
trickles or flutterbye? FLUTTERBYE
sanddollar or wave jumper? WAVE JUMPER
ss angel or ss crumpet?SS ANGEL
taf munchy or nightglider? NIGHTGLIDER
cool breeze or starry wings? COOL BREEZE
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? CROWN CLIP
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? SUNDAE PONY BARRETTES
baby leaper or baby racer? BABY RACER
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? BABY GAMETIME
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? MOMMY AND BABY
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? BABY SAPPHIRE
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? BABY LOLLIPOP
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? BABY PLUSH PONIES

And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory? PRINCESS WAND
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? BUBBLES
trickles or flutterbye? TRICKLES
sanddollar or wave jumper? SANDDOLLAR
ss angel or ss crumpet? SS CRUMPET
taf munchy or nightglider? TAF MUNCHY
cool breeze or starry wings? COOL BREEZE
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? CROWN CLIP
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? BRUSH N GROW
baby leaper or baby racer? BABY LEAPER
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? SUGARCAKE
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? MOMMY AND BABY
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? SAPPHIRE
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? SURPRISE NEWBORN
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? PJ PLUSH
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? BUBBLES
trickles or flutterbye? TRICKLES
sanddollar or wave jumper? WAVE JUMPER
ss angel or ss crumpet? CRUMPET
taf munchy or nightglider? MUNCHY
cool breeze or starry wings? STARRY WINGS
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? CLIP
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? SUNDAE
baby leaper or baby racer? LEAPER
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? SUGARCAKE
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? MOMMY AND BABY
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? SAPPHIRE
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? SURPRISE NEWBORN
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? BABY PLUSH

And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory?
HMM. I'M TORN BETWEEN PRINCESS CLIPS AND SQUIRREL TAIL CLIPS (from Happy Tails)
 
that's odd, i have a my pretty pony in pink and i can't give it away.
 
I can't say much for most of them but here's my homble opinion on the ones I do have such a thing about...
My pretty pony brown or pink? pink, I've actually seen the brown one before, but I don't own it
seashell or bubbles? Bubbles. I've now had FOUR Seashell's come into my hands, all in very good shape but only one bubbles.
sanddollar or wave jumper? no idea, I just got both in one box
ss angel or ss crumpet? Angel, I've seen a lot more crumpets
taf munchy or nightglider? Munchy, I've had three different NightGlider's but never a Munchy
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? don't care, I don't collect accessories so I wouldn't know, though I have a crown clip SOMEWHERE from my princess.
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? UK sleeping PJ plush ponies

I left out a few cause I really wouldn't know since I either don't collect the thing in question or I don't have either.

b.Nightmare
 
cobralily said:
that's odd, i have a my pretty pony in pink and i can't give it away.
Click to expand...

I'm having the same problem with the brown one. There's quite a few people with the pink one on their wishlists though, so you might want to search for it and try talking to some of those people. :)
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? BUBBLE
trickles or flutterbye? TRICKLES
sanddollar or wave jumper? SAND DOLLAR
ss angel or ss crumpet? SS CRUMPET
taf munchy or nightglider? TAF MUNCHY
cool breeze or starry wings? COOL BREEZE
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? PRINCESS CROWN CLIP
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? SUNDAE PONY BARETTES
baby leaper or baby racer? BABY RACER
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? BOTH, lol
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? RAPUNZEL
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? BABY SAPPHIRE
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? BABY LOLLIPOP
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? UK PJ PLUSHIES

And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory? Um...probably Rapunzel's barettes
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? Pink
seashell or bubbles? Bubbles
trickles or flutterbye? flutterbye
sanddollar or wave jumper? either
ss angel or ss crumpet? SS Cangel
taf munchy or nightglider? TAF Munchy i have never found her
cool breeze or starry wings? starry wings
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? any princess clip
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? princes BNG barrettes
baby leaper or baby racer? Baby leaper
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? i have never seen either so both
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? punzie, i only had her or seen her once
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? baby sapphire i had her once and i miss her :(
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? either
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? i quess the uk ones
 
1. Never look for pretty ponies so don't know
2. Seashell
3. Trickles
4. Can't remember the difference *slaps wrist*
5. SS Crumpet
6. TAF Munchy
7. Cool Breeze
8. A princess pony crown clip
9. Not sure, though I do have 1 sundae pony barrette
10. Baby Leaper
11. Haven't searched for these so not sure, though I'd try and buy them as a pair
12. Mommy and baby pony
13. I'd say Baby Sapphire
14. The yellow surprise newborn is pretty HTF
15. Well on UK ebay I prob see the PJ plushes more

And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory? Hmmm can't think of a certain single one, but the UK Sweet Kisses lipsticks come to mind, also I can't remember the last time I saw Good Weather's accessories for sale.
 
My pretty pony pink
bubbles?
flutterbye?
sanddollar
ss angel or ss crumpet? (neither were available here)
taf munchy
starry wings
princess pony crown clip
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? (no idea)
baby racer
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? (no idea)
mommy and baby pony?
uk ice crystal? (wasn't ice crystal only available in sweden or such?)
uk baby lollipop (surprise newborns were also availble outside the u.k.)
Uk sleeping pj plush
 
Pink
Seashell
Trickles
Sand Dollar
SS Angel
TAF Munchy
Starry Wings
A Princess Pony Crown Clip
Sundae Pony Barrettes
Bbay Leaper
Baby Gametime
Rapunzel
UK Baby Sapphire
UK SUrprise Newborn
UK Sleeping PJ Plush Ponies
 
I will only post the ones I've had experience with through searching the sales forums or ebay. Here is the result of my experiences:

trickles or flutterbye? TRICKLES
ss angel or ss crumpet? CRUMPET
taf munchy or nightglider? MUNCHY
cool breeze or starry wings? COOL BREEZE


And in your opinion what is the most hard to find mlp g1 accessory?
I'm afraid I can't say for this either as I don't actively seek out accessories. But I do know that the stacking toy can be very hard to find complete.
 
My pretty pony brown or pink? PINK
seashell or bubbles? Bubbles
trickles or flutterbye? trickels
sanddollar or wave jumper? both LOL
ss angel or ss crumpet? SS angel
taf munchy or nightglider? TAF munchy
cool breeze or starry wings? cool breeze
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? ??
 
I am going to answer these as to who I think is harder to find, rather than more sought after and valuable, because I think there tends to be confusion over the two.

My pretty pony brown or pink? Pink
seashell or bubbles? Bubbles
trickles or flutterbye? Trickles
sanddollar or wave jumper? Unsure
ss angel or ss crumpet? Crumpet
taf munchy or nightglider? Nightglider
cool breeze or starry wings? Cool Breeze
a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set? Princess Clip
sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes? PBnG Barrettes
baby leaper or baby racer? Baby Racer
baby gametime or baby sugarcake? Unsure
rapunzel or mommy and baby pony? Rapunzel
uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal? Ice Crystal
uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn? Baby Lollipop
Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies? UK Sleeping Bag
 
My pretty pony brown or pink?
pink

seashell or bubbles?
bubbles

trickles or flutterbye?
flutterbye

sanddollar or wave jumper?
dont know

ss angel or ss crumpet?
ss crumpet

taf munchy or nightglider?
taf nightglider

cool breeze or starry wings?
both equally

a princess pony crown clip or a complete big brother set?
princess pony crown clip

sundae pony barrettes or princess brush n grow barrettes?
sundae best pony barrettes

baby leaper or baby racer?
leaper

baby gametime or baby sugarcake?
both

rapunzel or mommy and baby pony?mommy and baby

uk baby sapphire or uk ice crystal?
dont know

uk baby lollipop or uk surprise newborn?
surprise newborn

Uk sleeping pj plush ponies or baby plush ponies?
sleeping pj plush
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top