MLPTP EVENT 2019 Halloween Swap wishlists


Festive FelizNavidad Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 3, 2006
Post your Halloween wishlists here once accepted into the swap :zombie:


Air-Conditioned Nightmare
MLPTP Supporter
Apr 15, 2017
Pony Wishlist
  • G1:
    • Locket
    • Swirly Whirly
    • Magic Star: Tootsie Pose
    • SS Heartthrob
    • SS Lickety Split
    • Love Melody
    • Princess Serena
    • Pillow Talk
  • G3
    • Abra-ca-dabra
    • Sparklesnap
    • Rainbow Flash
    • Tea Leaf's Accessories (Robe and mask)
    • Apple Spice
    • Ponyville figures (any are good! Any doubles will be customized)
  • G4
    • Cutie Mark Crew Chrysalis
    • Pinkie Pie (Pinkie's Boutique Brushable, Black hair/Purse release)
    • Rarity (Rainbow Rocks EQG + Pony set (pony only), with cutie mark over eyes)
  • Ok!
    • Writing on hoof, tiny symbol/eye/paint rubs, haircuts of any severity (g1+3 only), small marks that may sunfade out, messy tinsel
  • Yikes!
    • Brown spots, head/body mismatch, haircuts on G4 ponies, missing symbols, bite marks, holes, severe discoloration
  • I have Celiac Disease!This means I cannot have any candy/snacks that contain wheat, rye, barley, ingredients derived from those, or anything that says it was manufactured in a plant that processes foods that contain those ingredients. I understand if you just want to avoid shopping for candy altogether, really, it's fine! However, if you are able to find anything that is gluten free and not manufactured in a plant processing gluten-containing foods...
    • I LOVE caramel. I have yet to find any caramel that is gluten free, but I haven't been looking too hard. I also love rice crispy things, hazelnut, bubblegum lollipops, white chocolate (I think Reese's white chocolate is gluten free as long as it isn't a pumpkin shape? They're weird.), chocolate of any cacao percentage, and marshmallow. Again, I understand it's a lot to navigate the ingredients and am 100% fine with candy being skipped for more cozy extras! :satisfied:
    • I hate tootsie rolls. Gross. I also dislike whole nuts (aside from hazelnuts), coffee flavors, and popcorn balls.
  • Pony is my first love but I also collect Lalaloopsy horses! I only have three but any extras will be....customomized :0 So if you have any layin' around I'd love them. I also like Pusheen, and Pokemon (Eeveelutions and the popplio line mostly. I also have a big soft spot for older Garfield stuff.
  • As far as general extras go, I love socks! I'm a size 10 in US womans feets. I also love fabricwork, so scraps of fabric (especially if they're autumnal) or fun embroidery floss colors are fun. Doll hair, stickers, stationary (I do bullet journal!), (gluten free) teas (herbal, green, or fun autumn flavors are my fave!). Any props or paper for photoshoots are welcome as well. I do NOT wear jewelry or makeup, but I wouldn't be against a fun hair accessory of the spooky variety.
  • For more pony stuff, I love dressing up my ponies! Ribbons, clothing, fabric to become clothing, it's all fun! Twilight Sparkle is my favorite G4, I have a Sunny Daze army, and Wave Runner is my favorite G1.
  • As far as Halloween goes, my new um. Condition will probably make me a bit sour toward the day itself so if I don't have a night class I'll be helping decorate the house instead of gorging on candy like usual. I LOVE LOVE LOVE cats and black cats and anything about them. Witch hats are really appealing to me, and purple+green is my favorite Halloween exclusive color combo. Other than that, anything generally autumn is great!!! I actually like Thanksgiving much more, ha. Creepy motifs are neat, though.
I think I got everything, but if there are group questions I'll be adjusting this posting as necessary!
Last edited:


Ctarl-ctarl Outlaw Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 18, 2006
General pony wishlist::

I am not a super picky collector. So small marks/symbol rubs/haircuts are ok. Have a perfect pony with bad hair? I don't mind rehairs as long as it's the right color/style for that pony. I will take Fireflies in any condition for my army.

Halloween goodies:

Only candy no-no is black licorice. No allergies. I love anything with chocolate, nuts & caramel. Also fruity candies are delish. :) I also love homemade goodies; food or otherwise. Do you bake, sew, or have another creative outlet? Some of my favorite swap gifts are handmade, so feel free to put a little bit of your craft in my box. ;) But if it is time restrictive no pressure, I know how life gets

My Halloween decor runs on the cute/macabre side; but I don't mind a little gore. I love zombies, & animal skeletons. I have a little zombie goose that would like some friends. I also used to drive an old Buick hearse many years ago; it's still one if my favorite cars & I have a smattering of hearse nick-nacks.

Have fun!20190831_141226.png
Last edited:


So Soft Pony, So hard to clean
MLPTP Supporter
Sep 24, 2012
You can find my full pony wishlist here:

As you can see my wishlists for G1 + G3 are getting very small, so I understand that it'll be hard to find ones that fit under the price limits. If things are hard to find, I don't mind any of the boxed Basic Fun 30th anniversary retro ponies. I have the 25th anniversary release of the original 6 collector's pose ponies... but the Rainbow Ponies, Unicorns + Pegasi, etc. would be welcome. Another option could be the MLP Funko POPs, vinyl figures, blind bags, or blind box figurines. I don't really have any of those, so anything should be good. No particular preference.

Acceptable flaws:
light wear
surface dirt
writing on hooves
slightly rusty ok, I can clean
messy/kinda frizzy hair I can work with, too

Not acceptable flaws:
pen, sharpie, or highlighter marks
hair cuts
bite marks/holes
major paint rubs
(cigarette/cigar) smoke

I collect pins, with a particular love of Disney pins. I also like Olympic pins. I love most things Disney, especially the Disney Ducks, Ducktales, and Darkwing Duck. Other fandom things I love are Back to the Future, Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy 6 + 7, Legend of Zelda, One Piece (faves: Zoro + Sanji), and Pokemon (fave: Eeveelutions).

Halloween-y likes:
I'm more on the light and cute end of Halloween with my preferences. I like the not-so-scary stuff like Ghostbusters, Beetlejuice, and the Nightmare Before Christmas. I like black cats, witches, cute ghosts, jack-o-lanterns, etc. No spiders or bugs though, please. Candy-wise, I love milk chocolate. No nuts though, please. I also like sugar candy. Do not like licorice. Cute Halloween-y-themed socks, gloves or a scarf would be welcome, and I like the fall colours of deep reds, burnt umber/orange, yellow orchre... think of fall trees and all their colours. :3 I like autumn imagery.
Last edited:


Festive FelizNavidad Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 3, 2006
I only have international ponies left on my list, I know that can be a hassle so if you just want to get accessories that is totally fine!

I'm not too picky, no major hair cuts, or really bad marks, no chewed on or missing limbs! I don't like head/body color mismatch but little flaws or marks and such don't bother me.

I like cooking/baking and decorating for the holidays. I love Snoopy/Peanuts, Eeyore, Garfield and I also collect Charming Tails. I have a dachshund, Frank who is my fur-baby :) so I tend to collect dachshund stuff too. I also like mice but not Mickey, nothing against good 'ol Mickey but I just like cute mice stuff. I like fun socks and jewelry, particularly earrings.
As far as Halloween stuff goes I like cute Halloween themed stuff, I'm not really into the gross/gory stuff. I like it all, bats, pumpkins, witches, ghosts...I get into all the holidays and love this time of year!

None! I am trying to diet though, so little or no treats is ok with me. If you find you can't resist, I like chocolate, peanut butter and toffee and since it's that time of year, of course pumpkin too! If you're international, I do love trying new things from different countries.


Resident Music Goddess
MLPTP Supporter
Jun 9, 2005
I have a more extensive wish list here:
And here:

I will be happy with anything from my list!

major haircuts - severely knotted/matted hair - major paint rubs - permanent marks - chew marks/holes - large age spots and/or mold - cigarette smoke odor

frizzy hair - minor hair trims (<1/2") - surface dirt - small age spots (especially if they can be hidden) - broken neck seals - writing/initials on feet

The Pony Short-List
Lemon Drop
Baby Sea Shimmer (Year 3)
Baby Surf Rider (Year 3)
So-Soft Fifi
So-Soft Gusty
So-Soft Surprise
Baby Celebrate
Flutter Yum Yum
Pretty Vision
Cloud Dreamer
Baby Fifi
Baby Tic-Tac-Toe

Year three baby sea pony floats EXCEPT Tiny Bubbles'.

(Packaged ponies only for Basic Fun; I don't open them.)
Basic Fun Glory
Basic Fun Medley
Basic Fun Sunbeam
Basic Fun Pinwheel
Basic Fun Starflower

Cutie Mark Crew Series 1 Fin-tastic Field Trip
CMC S1 Star Students
CMC S2 Pony Applejack
CMC S2 Big Mac
CMC S2 Princess Celestia
CMC S2 Princess Luna
CMC S2 EG Rainbow Dash
CMC S2 EG Rarity
CMC S2 EG Sunset Shimmer
CMC S2 Seapony Twilight Sparkle
CMC S2 Party Performers
CMC S2 Party Style
CMC S3 all blind packs
CMC S3 Championship Party
CMC S3 Tea Party
CMC S4 all blind packs
CMC S4 Sightseeing Fun
CMC S4 Snow Day

The Loyal Subjects Action Vinyls Gusty
TLS AV Lickety-Split

Other Likes
Halloween is one of my favorite holidays! I love decorating - harvest, forest animals, pumpkins, black cats, ghosts, witches, skeletons.
Apple cider > pumpkin spice. I said it. Sorry.
I do like pumpkin-scented things, though. Pumpkin apple is the best of both worlds!
The Nightmare Before Christmas
Harry Potter
(I like the books and the movies.)
The Halloween Tree
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown

I love baking - cupcakes and cookies are my jam. I put sprinkles on everything!
The 1980s - music, movies
White German Shepherds
Black cats
Lisa Frank
Ritter Sport Marzipan and Corn Flakes bars
Gummy Krabby Patties
Kinder Joy
I really like those black- and orange-wrapped peanut butter taffies (Mary Janes?) that nobody likes.
Candy corn
Caramel Apple Milky Way
Milky Way Midnight

Grape-flavored anything
Banana-flavored anything
Root beer
Clowns - if you send me anything clown-related, I will burn the entire package.
Candles and wax tarts - I have too many already.
Makeup and body care items - again, I have too many already and can only use specific brands.

Cigarette smoke
Cats - mostly the really floofy ones for some reason
That said, I do have a cat and a dog, so... :blink::blink::blink:
Last edited:

Winged Mirage

Rainbow Rainbow Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Mar 18, 2018
Hi! I mostly collect G1, G2, and G3. I’m not too picky about the condition: as long as they don’t have haircuts, cancer, major rubs or chew marks I’m good. I also like stuff out of box, so there’s not much point buying unopened stuff for me. I want to display my ponies, and I don’t want to mess up new packaging because I know how much that affects something’s value later.

In a similar line, I don’t care about the clothes or other accessories. I just want the ponies.

Non-BBE Baby Heartthrob (main want)
Baby Rainribbon
Baby AppleJack
Princess Royal Purple or Pink
Baby Moondancer
Valentine’s Day Babies
Yum Yum (Twice as Fancy)
Pina Colada
Dancing Butterflies
Baby Dancing Butterflies
Baby Flicker
Baby Luckyleaf
Baby Tic-Tac-Toe
Morning Glory (Year 9)
Pretty Vision
Princess Moondust
Princess Starburst
Baby Paws
Cranberry Muffins
Mint Dreams
Star Glow
Star Hopper
Sweet Tooth
Baby Sweet Tooth
Blueberry Baskets
Bright Eyes
Color Mist
Crystalline (main want)
Lucky the Stallion
Sugar Apple
Wind Walker
Wind sweeper
Love Petal (main want)

Other: anything Hearthrob-related really


Miss Chef
Princess Crystal
Globe Trotter
Golden Glow
Silver Glow
Copper Glow
Lady Waterfall
Miss Painter
Prince Blue Dream
Night Star
Prince Firefly
Diamond Glow
Diamond Glow (magic)
Princess Silver Swirl
Star Swirl (Magic)
Tender heart
Glittery Study
Hip Hop (Miss Gadget)

I’m not interested in variations of the ponies I already have, unless they look significantly different.

Other: any G2 merchandise really.

Out of box Comi Con ponies, particularly the Egyptian one.
Henna Makeup-style ponies (McDonald’s or full ponies)
Always & Forever
Cloud Climber
Fairy Dust
Finger Paints
Royal Twist
Snow’el 2
Amazing Grace
Flower Garland
Kimono 2
Princess Peppermint
Rarity (any version)
Secret Wish
Serendipity (diva pose)
Sunrise Song
Sweet berry
Sparkleworks 2
Tangerine Twinkle
Anchors Away
Merriweather 1
Pretty Pop
Summer Bloom
December Poinsetta
Minty 7 (2008 Winter)
Aurora Mist
Marshmallow Coco
Silver Glow
Tropical Surprise 1
Chocolate Chipper
December Delight
Fizzy Pop
Round n Round
Royal Rose
Star Dasher
Star Shimmer
Tink-a-tink-a-too 2
Twilight Twinkle
Twinkle Hope
Velvet Bow

Other: nothing comes to mind really

Everything else:

I don’t want food. I’m diabetic so there are only certain things I can eat. Save all that good stuff for yourselves :p

I really enjoy Halloween, since I like dark and spooky stuff. I like black cats.

I love plushies. Just any kind of plushie. If it’s from Pokémon or Sonic, even better :D. Halloween themed plushies are also welcome!

I like body washes from Bath and Body Works. Some of my favorites are Dark Kiss, Sweet Pea, and Cucumber Melon. If you can’t find those, anything sweet-smelling and fruity will do lol. I’m well stocked on body sprays and don’t need anymore atm lol.

Stickers and small notepads are always fun, with cute or pretty things like animals and flowers. And I always need pens (though I prefer pens that write in thicker, bolder lines so it’s easier for me to see, like Papermate Profile 1.4B).

I also like books! Particularly fantasy, sci-fi, mystery/thriller, myths, philosophy, and, appropriate to the holiday, horror books. These can be new or used, as long as it’s not unreadable or falling apart I’m good :)

If you have any questions, just ask!


80s Glam Rock Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Oct 18, 2017
You can view my wish list here. (I am working on putting together a more user friendly list.)

Acceptable Flaws: Anything that is easily fixable (for G1). G4 I prefer mib or in euc.

Unacceptable Flaws: Please no drastic hair cuts, cancer, non-fixable marks (market/highlighter/etc), no chew/bites/holes/missing appendages, no weird smells (smoke/mold/cat pee)... basically if it’s not an “easy fix” to display I’d say pass on it.

Food Things: I love chocolate, specifically milk and white. I also enjoy gummies and Oreos (anything with Oreo in it) of all flavours. I have no food allergies so no troubles there.
I do not like mint flavoured chocolates/candies, cream eggs, black licorice.

Halloween-y likes: I like fun cute things too. I love Hocus Pocus (My all time fav Halloween movie), not so Halloween but I love Stranger Things, old school Jim Henson stuff, Beetlejuice, Ghostbusters (mainly Slimer). I no longer dress up or go to parties because my friends and I are “too old.” Themed “no show” socks are always good for me.

Other Interests: I also am a Disney lover of all sorts, but I love Stitch. I love anything Harry Potter/Fantastic Beasts! I also love the new She-Ra line of dolls, specifically Glimmer and Catra, Auora and Bow are cool too but the other two are my favourites. I also love Shih Tzu or Pug related things. Stationary things like notes books, pens, stickers, things I can use at work. Crafty things I can use for pony fixing like new hair, acrylic paints, extra fine glitter, tinsel are all great things. Ummm basically I’m a bit of a nerd for all things animation and cute. Obviously I love any MLP merch. :p

My favourite ponies: Shady (G1), Lickety Split (G1), Surprise (G1), Wind Whistler (G1), Pinkie Pie (G4), Fluttershy (G4), Starlight Glimmer (G4), Sunburst (G1&4) & Spike is the best!!

Favourite Colours: Teal & Pink

Okay! I think that covers everything. Please let me know if I’ve missed anything. :)
Last edited: