MLPTP EVENT ~*~ Easter Swap 2019 Wishlists ~*~


Festive FelizNavidad Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 3, 2006
Once accepted to the Easter swap be sure to post your wishlists here!


Festive FelizNavidad Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 3, 2006

I'm not too picky, no major hair cuts, or really bad marks, no chewed on or missing limbs LOL! But little flaws or marks and such don't bother me. I know I've got some pricier ponies on my list, it's just cause I'm so close to finishing the US collection but I am totally happy with accessories!

I like cooking/baking and decorating for the holidays. I love Snoopy/Peanuts, Eeyore, Garfield and I also collect Charming Tails. I have a dachshund, Frank who is my fur-baby :) so I tend to collect dachshund stuff too. I also like mice but not Mickey, nothing against good 'ol Mickey but I just like cute mice stuff. I like fun socks and jewelry, particularly earrings. My favorite colors are greens and purples.

None! I am trying to diet though, so go easy on the treats for me. I know that's hard for Easter! My favs are chocolate, peanut butter and toffee. If you're international, I do love trying new things from different countries.
Last edited:


Resident Music Goddess
MLPTP Supporter
Jun 9, 2005
The short-list is below. If you're looking for a more extensive list, view my Wishing Well thread. If you're still looking for something, view my most comprehensive wish list at MLP Merch (WARNING: the MLP Merch list takes a LOOOONG time to load).

I prefer G3s and G4s in package (I save parts of the packaging).

Unacceptable flaws: Major haircuts, knotted/matted hair, major paint rubs, permanent marks, chew marks/holes, mold or large age spots, cigarette smoke smell

Acceptable flaws: Frizzy hair, slight hair trims, surface dirt, small age spots (especially if they can be easily hidden), broken neck seals (on G1s only), writing/initials on feet

Allergies: Cigarette smoke, dust, some cats (stuff from pet-friendly homes is generally OK for me)

Likes: Cadbury chocolate ('tis the season for caramel eggs), Kinder Joy, Finders Keepers (Pony edition), Ritter Sport Marzipan and Cornflakes, gummy Krabby Patties, cute stickers, Lisa Frank, unicorns, rainbows, purple, bath bombs, the Target Dollar Spot/Bullseye's Playground, White German Shepherds, black cats, Harry Potter, those "aloe-infused" fuzzy socks, sprinkles and cupcake wrappers, MLP merchandise

Dislikes: Anything grape- or banana-flavored, candles/wax melts, lotions/sprays

skig's Pony Wish List
G1 Lemon Drop
G1 Sprinkles
G1 Curly-haired Applejack
G1 Curly-haired Bow-tie
G1 Baby Sea Shimmer (first wave Baby Sea Pony)
G1 Baby Surf Rider (first wave Baby Sea Pony)
G1 lavender Ember (with star symbol)
G1 Twinkle-Eye Sky Rocket
G1 Twinkle-Eye Sweet Pop
G1 SHS Wild Flower (with earring intact and unbroken)
G3 Morning Monarch
G3 Cheerilee II (Make-Up)
G3 Pinkie Pie II (Make-Up)
G3 Rainbow Dash IV (Make-Up)
G3 Scootaloo III (Make-Up)
G3 Starsong (Make-Up)
G3 Sweetie Belle (Make-Up)
G3 Toola Roola II (Make-Up)
G3 Cheerilee (Name)
G3 Blank Pony
G4 All About DJ Pon-3
G4 All About Starlight Glimmer
G4 All About Cheerilee
G4 All About Photo Finish
G4 Crystal Pearl
G4 Ocean Gem
G4 Sea Foam
G4 Sun Twist
G4 Flash Feather
G4 Flutter Cloud
G4 Cutie Mark Crew (any from Series 3)
G4 Mashmallows (any)
Last edited:


So Soft Pony, So hard to clean
MLPTP Supporter
Sep 24, 2012
For ponies: I'm looking for them to be in generally "good" condition, not too many flaws (or at least noticable flaws). I know that gets harder as the ponies get older... but basically I'd prefer if there are no permanent marks, no hair cuts, no large paint rubs, no body damage, no smooze/mold/etc., & prefer they come from non-smoking homes. Small things that are not really noticeable, or that I can clean off is okay. Don't really care if ponies (G3 or G4) are MIB or not, because I'd be unboxing them anyway. (lol)

Non-pony stuff: Easter-wise, I think bunnies are just adorable. :3 I love plain milk chocolate, and Cadbury's creme eggs! No food allergies.

I'm a fan of Disney, particularly the Disney ducks (Donald, Scrooge, Ducktales & Darkwing Duck). I collect Disney pins & Olympic pins (but really anything goes!) I like the following fandoms: One Piece, Transformers (Autobots FTW), Zelda series, Mario series, Star Trek, Star Wars, Back to the Future, Ghostbusters, Pokemon, Final Fantasies 6 & 7, Chrono Trigger/Cross... stop me or else I'll go on forever. XD

WISHLISTS: please see the attached pictures for my various wishlists for this swap, sorted by generation. (I'm in the middle of re-doing my full wishlist). I collect G1, G3, and G4 brushables. I'm not up-to-date on current pony values, so if any of the ponies listed here are beyond the price range, please ignore their inclusion on these lists. (also ignore the numbering on some of these ponies, especially the G4s... they're just for my own organizational needs).

.G1:23230 .G3:23231 .23232.G4: 23233 .23234 G4 FS: 23254

[edit:] 3/10: G4 Fashion Style added
Status of wanted G1s MIGHT be changing... pending response.
Last edited:


Flat Foot Peachy
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 16, 2014
Pony wish list:
G1 Ponies:

So soft Truly

So soft Taffy

So soft Skippety Doo

So soft Wind Whistler

TWE Sweet Pop


Sweet Lily


Blueberry Baskets

Sugar Apple

Confetti (US version)


Baby Racer

Baby waddles

Teeny tiny twins ~ Rattles and Tattles, Bootsie and Tootsie

Pony Condition Preferences: I prefer ponies without cancer, major pen marks and major hair cuts. I hate regrind but a little is acceptable for harder to find ponies! I don't mind some imperfections as long as the symbol and eyes are good, small rubs are ok. Small hair trims and marks to bottom of feet are ok too
Extra info:

My favourite colours are pink and blue.
My favourite scents are fall and winter scents such as cinnamon, spice, cranberry. I like liquid soaps, shower gels, body lotion

I like any MLP G1 retro Merchandise and I also have a Lickety Split army and love all things ice cream themed

I am also a big fan of Peanuts ~ Snoopy in particular. I also love disney stuff. Favourite characters are Winnie the Pooh, Mickey and Minnie, Aristocats, Alice in Wonderland. I like stickers, stationary items such as pens, pencils, notepads, post its or fridge magnets, shopping bags. I love lip balms and I like homemade items and art.
Favourite animals: cats, owls and rabbits.

I am not particularly religious but we do celebrate Easter. I like cutie Easter things such as Easter bunnies, chicks, cute Easter eggs. I have a 6 year old son so any Easter craft supplies or kits, decorations would be welcomed

I like milk chocolate, white chocolate, marshmallow and gummy sweets and laffy taffy. I would like to receive some Easter themed sweet treats local to you.

I also like savoury snacks especially cheese crunchy Cheetos

I like drinking coffee and hot cocoa especially topped with marshmallows!

Things to avoid: I am not so keen on floral scents

Anything flavoured Tea, coconut, marzipan, Turkish delight, peanut butter

I don't have any allergies

CJ Thimble Bright

Dancing in a room by myself
MLPTP Supporter
Apr 9, 2010
Well, let's see here... It's been around 4 years since I've done one of these, let's see if I remember how!

PONY: You can find my full G1 Pony Wish List here (I attempted to update it the best I could with the collection in storage). I also love G1 merchandise, original and retro new! Mugs, keychains, cups, ornaments (I do have the Hallmark Cotton Candy, Moondancer and Firefly ones), magnets, purses... you name it and it will make me happy! As mentioned at the bottom of my pony list, I have a small Moondancer army that I'm always looking to add to.

Unacceptable flaws: major cuts to hair, no tail rust, cancer/mold, marker/stains on the body (under the feet are okay, if it's a harder to find pony), no holes or chewed spots, major paint rubs, cigarette smell (or other strong odor that isn't pony).

No known allergies.

Please keep the snacks/candies to a minimum as I am trying to lose weight. But 1 or 2 won't kill me. :) I do love chocolate, peanut butter, and caramel, and Cadbury Mini Eggs are delightful... I drink coffee daily and sometimes also tea. If you are from a different country, or from a different part of the US, I LOVE trying things that are special to different regions. I'm pretty food adventurous, so you don't have to worry.

OTHER THINGS: I have a fat, striped, ginger and white cat, as well as my husband's tiny flame point siamese cat that both enjoy treats and toys. I also have 2 green cheek conures (small parrots) that run my life. I enjoy sewing and crafting, I have an obsession with Christmas cotton fabrics (I can do AMAZING things with just a 1/2 yard!). I'm currently working on a "string quilt" which is my first foray into full-sized quilting. But I also like making clothing and small things. I love red cardinals (from my short time in MI) and feed the wild birds here in AZ. I'm trying to build a container garden with herbs, veggies, and flowers and am obsessing over good seeds and bulbs right now. I am a dance teacher - primarily ballet. But I hate pink and glitter! lol. Favorite colors are most shades of purple, dark blue, and emerald green. Earrings and rings are things I wear daily and I also love fun socks (but no toe socks).

I hope that helps my partner... ask questions if I've left out anything pertinent!
Last edited:


80s Glam Rock Pony
MLPTP Supporter
Oct 18, 2017
You can view my wish list here.

Acceptable Flaws: Anything that is easily fixable (for G1). G4 I prefer mib or in euc.

Unacceptable Flaws: Please no drastic hair cuts, cancer, non-fixable marks (market/highlighter/etc), no chew/bites/holes/missing appendages, no weird smells (smoke/mold/cat pee)... basically if it’s not an “easy fix” to display I’d say pass on it.

Food Things: I love chocolate, specifically milk and white. I also enjoy gummies and Oreos of all flavours. I have no food allergies so no troubles there.
I do not like mint flavoured chocolates/candies, cream eggs, black licorice.

Other Interests: I also am a Disney lover of all sorts, but I love Stitch. I also love Toothless (How to Train Your Dragon) and his new lady... like seriously so friggin cute! I love anything Harry Potter/Fantastic Beasts! I also love Shih Tzu or Pug related things. Stationary things like notes books, pens, stickers, cute washi tape, things I can use at work. Ummm basically I’m a bit of a nerd for all things animation and cute. Obviously I love any MLP merch. :p

My favourite ponies: Shady (G1), Lickety Split (G1), Surprise (G1), Wind Whistler (G1), Pinkie Pie (G4), Fluttershy (G4), Starlight Glimmer (G4), Sunburst (G1&4) & Spike is the best!!

Favourite Colours: Teal & Pink

Okay! I think that covers everything. Please let me know if I’ve missed anything. :)


Pied Piper of Ponies
MLPTP Supporter
Jan 20, 2018
I'm not a super picky collector, but no cancer, missing parts, marks that won't come off, major hair cuts. I'm not a big fan of chocolate, but I love wine gums and red/black licorice. I love healthier treats. I love kitties. My favourite colour is red, but I love all bright colours.

G1 Ponies still needed

Year 1

FF Blossom

Year 2
CF Blue Belle
Sealight’s shell

Year 3
Curly hair Bowtie
Trickles Rainbow pony upgrade
Seabreeze and shell
High Tide and shell
White Cap’s shell or repro
Wave Jumper and shell
Sea Mist and shell
Sand Dollar’s shell or repro
Sea Star
Sea Shimmer

Year 4
BBE Baby Halfnote
BBE Baby Tiddywinks
BBE Baby Cuddles
Snowball puppy
Celebrate from party pack
All 6 McDonald’s Collector charms

Year 5
Friendly (blue) bushwoolie
Eager (dark pink)
Cheery (pink)
Wavy and float
Surfy and float
Sea spray and float
Dipper and Float
Sea breeze and float
Salty and float
SS Crumpet
Newborn twin Rattles
Pillow Talk
Pink Dreams
Night Cap
Sleepy head
Sweet Dreams

Year 6
Coco Berry
All mommy charms
TAF Munchy
BNG Twisty tail
Princess Sunbeam
Princess Misty
Princess Moondust
Princess Dawn
Newborn twins speckles,
HT Squeezer
Tall Tales
Baby Graffiti
Watercolour sea ponies Foamy and float
Misty and float
Sealight and float
Wave Dancers and float
Seawinkle and float
SW Lady Flutter
SweetBerry Boysenberry Pie
Raspberry Jam
Cranberry Muffins
Cha Cha
Cat nip

Year 7
CC Caramel Crunch
Sunshine Mainsail
Beach Ball
TAF Megan
Fancy pants Baby Bows
Baby Starburst
Dance and prance Twirler
Tap Dancer
Daddy Sweet Celebrations
WW Whirly
Starry Wings
Sparkle pony Twinkler
Baby Stripes
Baby Nectar
Baby Lucky Leaf
Baby Leafy
Baby Pockets
Baby Hoppy
SHS Flowerburst
Frilly Flower

Year 8
Drink and wet Snookums
SHS Sweet Sundrop
Cha cha
Daisy Dancer

Year 9
Flower Dream
Garden glow
Precious pocket Sweet pocket
Bunny Hop
Half Note
Baby Brightbow
Baby Sunribbon
Secret Surprise Secret Star

Secret Beauty
Pretty Puff
Teeny Tiny Little tabby
Little Whiskers
Pink Princess pony

Year 10
Colourswirl Lovebeam
Paradise baby Beach ball
Sundazzle Sunbeam
Teeny Tiny Rattles
Purple sweet talkin
Lovin’ kisses
Flower Fantasy sweet blossom
Fancy mermaid pearly
Sea princess
Sea Shimmer

Big brother hats and bandannas for Wigwam, 4 speed, Steamer and Quarterback

International Ponies needed

Activity Club Baby Ponies
Baby Ponies (First Edition)
UK babies, Lemon Drop, Gusty, Ribbon
Tutti Frutti
Any Dragon that came with Princess ponies
Good Weather

All Sweet Kisses ponies

Non so soft Wind Whistler, Gusty, Shady, Magic Star, Buttons

Sea Ponies
Surf Dancer with Shell
Wave Breaker with Shell
Sea Spray with Shell

Playschool Baby Ponies
Schooltime Ponies

Starlight Baby Ponies (except Baby Mischief)

Flower ponies (except Daffodil)

7 Tales (except Clover)

Cookery Ponies

Good Weather

Romance Ponies Love Letter

Nurse Ponies

Rollerskate ponies

Great hair ponies

Hair do ponies

Berry Town family
Meadowsweet Family
Dad and mom Sunbright

Best Friend Ponies

Sweetie babies

Jewelry ponies

Seaside ponies except Splosh

Baby Sunset and Stargaze

35th Anniversary Firefly (MIB preferably)
35th Anniversary Moondancer (MIB preferably)
35th Anniversary Glory (MIB preferably)
35th Anniversary Twilight (MIB preferably)
Last edited:


Little Pretty Kitty
MLPTP Supporter
Aug 5, 2011
Wish list (G1):
Baby Northstar (first tooth)
Cloud Puff
NBBE Baby Half Note
Baby Noddins
NBBE Baby Cuddles (drink n wet)

Wishlist (G4-4.5)
Cutie Mark Crew Derpy
Sparkly Princess Luna
Equestria Girls Fashion Squad Rarity (mini doll)
Any Cutie Mark Crew figures beyond wave 1

I also love customs!!!

Flaws that are OK:
slight smells, marks on bottoms of hooves, some dirt, small marks/ scuffs that aren't in the eyes or on the cutie mark, slight haircuts (not a buzzcut), slight tail rust, I'm pretty easy going.

Flaws that are not OK:
Cancer, any kind of mold, intense odors, anything that looks like it needs to be gutted and cleaned.

Other things my partner should know:
I have diabetes, so no big sugary sweets please! Sugar free is fine (no grape or coffee flavors), I also like chips and pretzels and stuff like that. Or sugar free gum even.
My favorite ponies are Rarity and Derpy.
My favorite color is pink, but I love pastel colors too.
I love cats, possums, octopi and squids.
I also like Pokemon, Monster High, Barbie, space stuff, and blind bag toys.