MLPTP EVENT Who’s that Ghost Chatter WINNER ANNOUNCED

yourpinkoverlord said:
I originally wrote "Either she didn't realize or she purposefully worded it in a vague way" but then changed it because it almost sounded like metagaming.
Click to expand...
My pretty pony is spendy and cp.... I just don't like guessing high price ponies.
 
Tak said:
I made my random guess of the day. I'm asking if the g1 has a gimmick next. I.E. sparkle, winger, scented, glow, etc. Then comes tinsel. :tongue:
Click to expand...
I was trying to figure out how to word that earlier but ended up asking something else cause I thought it might not count as one question :smile:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I came back after taking a break, and am so confused haha
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
Tak said:
I made my random guess of the day. I'm asking if the g1 has a gimmick next. I.E. sparkle, winger, scented, glow, etc. Then comes tinsel. :tongue:
Click to expand...
Ha yes, this is also my next strategy. There are so many G1s, so this will probably take ages. :lolpony:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
So... 5 ponies. g1 daisy dancer, g3 rainbow flash, g4 pinkie pie, g4.5 potion nova, fifth pony?

Yes, one blue, possible shs, there is purple, g1 has some pink, g1 has and doesn't have a plant themed symbol, one g3, one g1, the g4 has been in a reboot release, one g4, one g4.5, some multi colored hair.

No Pegasus, hqg1c, not a Fakie, bb, spike, g1 is not white with purple hair, no non pony g1, g1 is not a winger, g1 has not had a basic fun release, no cp, no purple g4, no orange, no yellow, no extra symbols on any, no babies, no ss, no g2, no flutters, no baby exists of the g1, no seapony, no mpp, no g3.5, no second g4.5 with muticolored hair, no g1 or g4 unicorns.

Not g1 bowtie, silky slipper, shs cha cha, shs flowerrburst, tic tac toe, lemon drop, powder, starry wings, mgr sunny bunch, dnp player, shs flowerdream, Shs sweet sundrop, shs starflash, cotton candy, blossom, firefly, bb trucker, zig zag, princess royal blue, sun glider, or posey.
Not g4 rarity, blossomforth, dj pon, or cupcake, big mac, photo finish, Celestia, cheerile, twilight sparkle, or rainbow dash.
Not g3 seascape, garden glow, garden wishes, sweetie belle, cheerilee
Not g4.5 celestia, trixie
 
Last edited:
Not Oakley either

I’m wondering what to guess next
Hmm...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
There’s still some basics we don’t know, like what Gen the other two ponies are and that’s kinda important because stuff like “the G1 has a little bit of pink” is only helpful if we know how many G1 ponies there are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
yourpinkoverlord said:
This is not a drill! There is G4.5! I repeat, this is not a drill!
Luckily for us there aren’t many of them so this will be easier to guess.
Click to expand...
I think there have to be two G4.5 ponies.

5 total, one G1, one G3, one G4. And there explicitly aren't two G1s or two G4s - that was finally confirmed. Before a G4.5 being confirmed there was still room for there to be three G1s or three G4s. But with one of the two remaining slots confirmed as a G4.5, that room is gone.
 
Where's a good place for a list of G4.5 toys? Google is not being cooperative thus far.
The choices there would seem pretty limited by a question that was asked, and the non-G1 mystery has to be a G4.5 because the other gens have been eliminated. I mean, what else could it be?

As for the G1, we know it's an Earth Pony but can't be a regular one (because of the "yes and also no"). We know it has a little bit of pink, but not much (what led me to try Tic Tac Toe)... We also know it's not a So Soft, and it's probably not a Twice as Fancy either.

By the way, Skybreeze, thank you for that "No G1 unicorns under there" answer. That's what led me to Potion Nova (and why a previous guess was G3 Cheerilee).
 
ZeldaTheSwordsman said:
Where's a good place for a list of G4.5 toys? Google is not being cooperative thus far.
The choices there would seem pretty limited by a question that was asked, and the non-G1 mystery has to be a G4.5 because the other gens have been eliminated. I mean, what else could it be?

As for the G1, we know it's an Earth Pony but can't be a regular one (because of the "yes and also no"). We know it has a little bit of pink, but not much (what led me to try Tic Tac Toe)... We also know it's not a So Soft, and it's probably not a Twice as Fancy either.

By the way, Skybreeze, thank you for that "No G1 unicorns under there" answer. That's what led me to Potion Nova (and why a previous guess was G3 Cheerilee).
Click to expand...
I've been using MLPMerch. It's up-to-date on everything (as far as I know), including G4.5.
 
ZeldaTheSwordsman said:
Where's a good place for a list of G4.5 toys? Google is not being cooperative thus far.
The choices there would seem pretty limited by a question that was asked, and the non-G1 mystery has to be a G4.5 because the other gens have been eliminated. I mean, what else could it be?

As for the G1, we know it's an Earth Pony but can't be a regular one (because of the "yes and also no"). We know it has a little bit of pink, but not much (what led me to try Tic Tac Toe)... We also know it's not a So Soft, and it's probably not a Twice as Fancy either.

By the way, Skybreeze, thank you for that "No G1 unicorns under there" answer. That's what led me to Potion Nova (and why a previous guess was G3 Cheerilee).
Click to expand...
MLP Merch is best for quick identifications for most ponies. ;) No problem.

Just call me the Riddler.
Riddler.gif
 
Tak said:
So... 5 ponies. One earth g1, g3 rainbow flash, g4 pinkie pie, g4.5 potion nova, fifth pony?

Yes, one blue, possible shs, there is purple, g1 has some pink, one g1, the g4 has been in a reboot release, one g4, one identified g4.5 possibly a second, some multi colored hair.

No Pegasus, bb, spike, g1 is not white with purple hair, no non pony g1, g1 is not a winger, g1 has not had a basic fun release, no cp, no purple g4, no orange, no extra symbols on any, no babies, no ss, no g2, no flutters, no baby exists of the g1, no seapony, no mpp, no g3.5, no second g4.5 with muticolored hair, no g1 or g4 unicorns.

Not g1 bowtie, silky slipper, tic tac toe, lemon drop, powder, starry wings, mgr sunny bunch, dnp player, shs flowerdream, Shs sweet sundrop, shs starflash, cotton candy, blossom, firefly, bb trucker, zig zag, princess royal blue, sun glider, or posey.
Not g4 rarity, blossomforth, dj pon, or cupcake, big mac, photo finish, Celestia, cheerile, twilight sparkle, or rainbow dash.
Not g3 seascape, garden glow, garden wishes, sweetie belle
Not g4.5 celestia
Click to expand...
Updated
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top